MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
31 January 2023

5 Marketing Mistakes That Are Killing Your Business

4Frameworks
5Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Marketing6 steps

Best-Practice Augmentation Method

Use proven foundations, then diverge toward a higher-value customer outcome.

Read →
Leadership6 steps

Capability-First Hiring Scorecard

Evaluate learning, contribution, and adaptability before relying on résumé prestige.

Read →
Strategy5 steps

Multiple-Solution Decision Method

Generate several viable paths, test them cheaply, and select for context.

Read →
Strategy5 steps

Strategy-Systems-Process Sequence

Set the strategy first, align systems second, and design execution last.

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster16:00

Promotion to Management Can Destroy Specialist Value

The hosts challenge the assumption that management is the natural promotion for every outstanding individual contributor. As roles become more senior, practitioners are pushed toward generalism even when their specialist work creates more value and gives them greater satisfaction.

  • Traditional career ladders convert strong specialists into novice managers.
  • Exceptional individual contributors may be more valuable than many managers.
  • Prestige and compensation should not require direct reports.
  • Specialists need credible long-term advancement paths.

“we have created career paths that take people who are incredible at something and making them into a generalist of everything, right?”

Kieran Flanagan · 16:00

“A real path to earn great money with never having to touch management.”

Kieran Flanagan · 18:00
#management#career-paths#individual-contributors#talent

Hot Take· 3

Hot Take01:00

Remote Onboarding Is an Underserved AI Opportunity

Kieran's first week at Zapier gives him a fresh view of remote employee onboarding. He argues that an AI assistant trained on company knowledge could guide each employee through a consistent experience and answer routine questions.

  • Remote onboarding repeatedly exposes employees to similar questions and information.
  • A trained AI assistant could provide consistent, on-demand guidance.
  • The quality of the assistant depends on having suitable organizational data models.

“But there's a real, interesting business to be built in AI for employee onboarding.”

Kieran Flanagan · 01:00

“'Cause everyone's going through a consistent experience in having some sort of AI assistant to just onboard you through that, answer the questions.”

Kieran Flanagan · 01:00
#ai#onboarding#remote-work#hr-tech
Hot Take17:00

Marketing Is a Trade, Not a Purely Academic Discipline

Kipp frames marketing and sales as crafts learned through practice rather than credentials alone. Great marketers build and create, and organizations lose value when they push every strong practitioner toward management.

  • Practical repetition develops marketing expertise.
  • Marketers create tangible assets, campaigns, and systems like other craftspeople.
  • Academic credentials do not substitute for practicing the discipline.
  • Organizations should respect specialist craft as a durable career path.

“And I wanna tell you here and now, marketing is a trade. Like it is a trade.”

Kipp Bodnar · 17:30

“They are getting the marketing expertise they need through practicing that craft and that trade.”

Kipp Bodnar · 17:30
#marketing-careers#craft#education#specialists
Hot Take21:00

The Future Favors Exceptional Marketing Craftspeople

Kipp predicts that marketing will offer more opportunities for exceptional practitioners than for exceptional managers. He urges listeners to consider where future demand will be distributed when choosing which skills to develop.

  • Great management can still support a successful career.
  • The total number of elite management roles may contract.
  • Demand for exceptional builders and specialists is likely to remain broader.
  • Career planning should consider the future distribution of roles.

“the number of roles that will be available for people who are exceptionally amazing managers will be much smaller than the number of roles available…”

Kipp Bodnar · 21:00

“I just want you to be clear on where the distribution of the opportunity is.”

Kipp Bodnar · 21:30
#future-of-work#marketing-careers#management#skills

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway20:00

Managers Can Preserve Their Craft Through Hands-On Projects

Kieran explains how senior leaders can remain connected to the discipline even after entering management. His approach was to periodically participate in selected projects as a team member while trusted leaders handled the broader organization.

  • Management does not require abandoning hands-on craft entirely.
  • Selected projects can reconnect leaders with the work they enjoy.
  • Strong delegated leadership creates room for direct contribution.
  • Hands-on participation can preserve practical judgment.

“One of my ways was to every quarter, to nearly act like one of the team members under a certain couple of projects”

Kieran Flanagan · 20:30

“And then like, oh, on these things, I'm gonna act like a team member.”

Kieran Flanagan · 20:30
#leadership#management#hands-on-work#career-design