MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
18 November 2025

AI Just Broke Marketing (And What You Need to Do Now)

4Frameworks
9Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster09:00

Rising Search Volume Does Not Mean Websites Are Winning

Conversational AI can increase the number of searches while sharply reducing clicks to websites. The hosts argue that marketers should monitor click disappearance rather than interpret growing query volume as proof that traditional organic acquisition remains healthy.

  • AI conversations generate more queries than keyword search
  • Google results were already moving toward no-click answers
  • AI mode accelerates answer consumption without website visits
  • Click loss is more strategically important than total search volume

search volume is 100% going to increase. And that is not the thing to look at.

Kieran Flanagan · 10:30

The thing to look at is the disappearance of clicks.

Kieran Flanagan · 10:30
#search#zero click#seo#ai assistants
Myth Buster40:00

Taste Is Not Magic—It Is Trained Pattern Recognition

Taste is framed as accumulated exposure plus the ability to distinguish strong work from weak work. In an AI workflow, that judgment becomes valuable because people must repeatedly direct and select outputs rather than manually create every asset.

  • Taste comes from extensive exposure to examples
  • Experts learn to arbitrate between good and bad outputs
  • AI increases the value of selection and direction
  • Marketing roles may polarize toward engineering skill or exceptional taste

taste is not this arbitrary thing that people have or have not

Kip Bodnar · 40:30

taste means have I seen tens and hundreds of thousands of this thing and can I then arbitrate what good looks like and what bad…

Kip Bodnar · 40:30
#creative taste#ai skills#marketing careers#judgment

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take02:30

AI Content Slop Is Moving Trust from Brands to People

As AI-generated material becomes ubiquitous, audiences may increasingly filter information through people they already trust. The hosts argue that individual employees and creators are becoming the real public face and distribution layer of B2B brands.

  • AI-generated content is becoming a large share of the web
  • Visible AI spam can drive people away from undifferentiated feeds
  • Audiences increasingly trust recognizable individuals over corporate profiles
  • Human-led channels can outperform traditional brand-led content

The more content is generated by AI, the more I think people will switch towards trusting content from someone they trust, like an individual versus…

Kieran Flanagan · 04:00

all of those individual profiles are now what the brand actually is.

Kip Bodnar · 05:30
#ai content#creator economy#brand trust#b2b marketing

Explainer· 3

Explainer01:00

Why AI Is Moving Marketing from Volume to Value

Search disruption and rising paid acquisition costs are reducing the amount of measurable demand marketers can acquire efficiently. At the same time, AI gives teams more ways to personalize, qualify, and convert the demand they already have, shifting emphasis from traffic volume to customer value extraction.

  • Traditional measurable demand is becoming harder to acquire
  • Paid customer-acquisition costs are rising
  • AI is currently strongest at converting more of existing demand
  • Marketing economics are shifting from volume toward value

today, I think maybe we're in the era of value where we can acquire less measurable demand.

Kieran Flanagan · 02:00

AI really shines today as the ability to convert more of what you get.

Kieran Flanagan · 02:00
#ai marketing#demand generation#conversion#customer acquisition
Explainer13:30

AI Is Cannibalizing Educational and Transactional Search

Educational content was disrupted first because assistants can perform tasks instead of merely explaining them. Product recommendations and other transactional searches are now also moving into AI systems, weakening the assumption that commercial-intent queries will remain protected.

  • Assistants convert instructional information into direct action
  • Educational searches were cannibalized first
  • Transactional product discovery is now being affected
  • Companies cannot force customers back into preferred search habits

what happens with these AI assistants is they turn information into action.

Kieran Flanagan · 14:00

Go to markets are built based upon where consumer habits are going, not where you want them to go.

Kieran Flanagan · 15:00
#search behavior#transactional search#content marketing#ai agents
Explainer21:30

When AI Handles Targeting and Ads, Marketers Supply Data and Story

Google's AI Max is presented as evidence that ad platforms can increasingly automate targeting and creative execution. The marketer's comparative advantage shifts toward supplying differentiated data, allocating budget, and defining the story or message the system should test.

  • AI Max can perform targeting and ad creation
  • The system reportedly outperformed the team's paid marketers in tests
  • Data quality becomes a core input to platform performance
  • Story and campaign meaning remain important human responsibilities

you basically have the data and you have the money.

Kieran Flanagan · 22:00

Our role is to make sure that they have the best data set to build the best targeting in paid advertising ads

Kieran Flanagan · 23:00
#paid ads#google ai max#marketing data#automation

Tool· 1

Tool39:30

Create a Specialist AI Assistant for Video Prompting

The hosts suggest accelerating mastery of a new video model by asking a research assistant to produce a detailed onboarding document. That document can then ground a custom GPT that writes specialized prompts for the video tool.

  • Generate an onboarding document for the target video model
  • Include practical prompting guidance in the document
  • Load the document into a custom GPT
  • Use the grounded assistant to draft video prompts

One of the ways that you can get really good at VO3 prompting very very fast is actually have Perplexity or one of these assistants…

Kieran Flanagan · 39:30

now you have an assistant that can actually prompt for VO3 for you

Kieran Flanagan · 40:00
#video ai#prompting#custom gpt#content creation

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway07:00

Stop Appearing Only When Customers Search

An SEO-centric company appears primarily when a buyer actively asks a question. By adding newsletters, podcasts, YouTube, and creator channels, a brand can become present across the customer's normal day rather than occupying one isolated search moment.

  • Search captures only active question-answering moments
  • Podcasts and newsletters reach buyers during routine consumption
  • Channel diversification increases the number of meaningful touch points
  • Content planning should reflect how customers actually spend their day

you have to be part of the channels that they consume

Kieran Flanagan · 08:30

I wonder how much you consume from individuals versus how much you consume from brands.

Kieran Flanagan · 08:30
#distribution#content strategy#customer journey#b2b
Takeaway24:00

AI Lets B2B Marketing Move from Segments to Micro-Audiences

Traditional B2B targeting often relies on broad firmographic and geographic segments. AI enables many more granular campaigns and individualized email experiences, creating human-like relevance at conventional marketing scale.

  • Traditional B2B segments are often hypothetical and broad
  • AI supports smaller audiences and more granular creative
  • Teams can run many more campaign variations
  • Personalized email can approach human-message engagement at scale

the world of AI makes everything much more granular

Kip Bodnar · 24:30

now AI allows us to move to like these micro audiences and do much more marketing at scale for smaller groups

Kieran Flanagan · 25:30
#personalization#micro audiences#email marketing#segmentation