MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
02 June 2022

How Rationality F’s up your B2B Strategy

9Frameworks
13Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster09:00

The Formal Decision-Maker Does Not Control Every B2B Purchase

Kip challenges the assumption that B2B marketing should focus almost exclusively on senior decision-makers. Purchasing influence is often distributed across a team, making product sentiment, peer recommendations, and grassroots usage important parts of adoption.

  • Budgets and product choices are frequently distributed across teams
  • Employees can influence purchases without holding executive titles
  • Team-wide brand affinity creates internal momentum
  • Marketing can help prospective users before they become customers

My team decides 90% of what we do, right? And what we use, what we buy, how we spend our money.

Kip Bodnar · 09:30

I have no budget, right? Like there's no line item with my name on the budget. It's it's distributed across the team.

Kip Bodnar · 09:30
#b2b buying#decision makers#teams#brand affinity
Myth Buster31:00

Transformation Does Not Have to Sound Aspirational

The hosts use AWS to distinguish aspirational transformation from operational transformation. AWS changed how developers built and scaled products through accessible infrastructure and consumption-based pricing, even though its story was grounded primarily in functionality rather than lofty emotional messaging.

  • Functional improvements can create transformational behavior change
  • Emotion may emerge after users experience new capabilities
  • Operational transformation can be more credible for skeptical audiences
  • Aspirational messaging is only one form of transformation

not all transformation has to be aspirational.

Kip Bodnar · 33:00

The developer was like, Oh, I'm so proud of myself for being able to get this thing up and running and doing, or I'm so…

Kip Bodnar · 32:30
#aws#developers#transformation#product messaging

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take11:30

Stop Building Strategy Around This Year's Target Alone

Kip argues that annual targets should not be the starting point for business strategy. Companies should first decide how they intend to win their market over multiple years, then choose investments that can create category leadership, brand awareness, and durable word of mouth.

  • Begin with the ambition to win the market long term
  • Treat strategy as a multi-year problem
  • Balance current goals with a few asymmetric long-term bets
  • Accept that transformative investments may initially appear unreasonable

The first thought you should have is like, how do I win this market long term?

Kip Bodnar · 12:00

I want to be number one versus like I want to be okay.

Kip Bodnar · 12:00
#long-term strategy#market leadership#growth#strategic bets
Hot Take27:30

Every Successful Disruptor Eventually Becomes the Status Quo

A transformational company that wins its argument eventually turns its once-radical approach into standard practice. At that point it must master routine execution, protect itself from new challengers, or disrupt its own established model.

  • Winning transformation converts novelty into best practice
  • Category leaders eventually face defensive responsibilities
  • Operational excellence becomes critical after the market accepts the idea
  • Self-disruption can be safer than waiting for an outside challenger

Every transformational product positioning and brand eventually becomes best practice if you win that argument.

Kieran Flanagan · 27:30

once you disrupt the status quo, you become the status quo.

Kip Bodnar · 28:00
#disruption#status quo#category leadership#innovation

Explainer· 2

Explainer07:00

Why B2B Brands Should Build Beyond Their Buyer Niche

The hosts argue that B2B companies increasingly serve ecosystems of users, advocates, and eventual buyers rather than a small group of formal decision-makers. A large audience becomes a strategic asset that supports community, partnerships, distribution, recommendations, and future opportunities that cannot always be predicted upfront.

  • B2B has shifted from buyer-led toward user-led adoption
  • A large audience creates leverage beyond immediate lead generation
  • Communities can become owned media and partnership assets
  • Future strategic benefits may take years to emerge

People think too much about what is the most important thing today versus like what is the most important thing in the future.

Kieran Flanagan · 08:00

Like we have audience, which is a valuable commodity within that market and valuable commodity you can kind of use in interesting ways.

Kieran Flanagan · 08:30
#b2b#audience building#community#distribution
Explainer29:30

Companies Cannot Manufacture Transformation Without an External Force

Kip argues that companies do not independently change mass behavior; they capitalize on changes already being enabled by technology, society, or the environment. HubSpot's inbound-marketing story worked because the internet democratized publishing and weakened older channels such as directories and billboards.

  • Look for external forces already changing customer behavior
  • Use the product and message to facilitate that change
  • Do not confuse company persuasion with society-wide behavior change
  • Build a better version of existing practice when no external catalyst exists

You, as a company team of people, cannot change the behaviors of the world.

Kip Bodnar · 30:00

You can capitalize on behavior change that is facilitated by some environmental external change.

Kip Bodnar · 30:00
#transformation#behavior change#inbound marketing#market timing

Story· 1

Story11:00

How Loom Spread Through HubSpot From a Single User

Kieran recounts how one person began using Loom inside HubSpot before its use spread rapidly across the company. The story demonstrates how free or accessible products can establish value at the individual level and grow into organization-wide adoption.

  • One employee can initiate enterprise adoption
  • Visible utility encourages peer-to-peer product spread
  • Free access lets users prove value before requesting budget
  • Modern software adoption can begin from the bottom up

Loom, we were very, very early users of Loom. It started within my team and it just spread like wildfire.

Kieran Flanagan · 11:00

But just a great example of like one person decided to use Loom in HubSpot to do some of their own work, and that thing…

Kieran Flanagan · 11:00
#loom#product-led growth#adoption#hubspot

Q&A· 1

Q&A14:30

Should an Early Startup Hire a Product Marketer First?

Kieran argues that an early product marketer can clarify the customer, use case, problem, solution, positioning, sales collateral, and onboarding. Kip counters that conventional product marketing can narrow the discussion too quickly unless senior leadership first resolves broader questions about category, product constraints, and business strategy.

  • Early product marketing can sharpen use-case and customer clarity
  • Positioning can help attract more of the right customer cohort
  • Sales-led and product-led companies need different supporting assets
  • Category and business-model questions may require more senior ownership

So I actually think I do do the rational thing there. And I actually tell founders a single product marketer is a good early hire…

Kieran Flanagan · 16:00

Cause it's really a business strategy thing. It's not just marketing.

Kip Bodnar · 18:00
#product marketing#startups#positioning#hiring

Tool· 2

Tool01:00

Books and Newsletters for Becoming a Better Marketer

The hosts recommend broad, thought-provoking books alongside specialized resources on positioning, writing, product design, and entrepreneurship. They also highlight newsletters and science fiction as ways to sharpen strategic thinking and anticipate future trends.

  • Read broad books that challenge how you understand people and markets
  • Use specialized books to deepen skills such as positioning and copywriting
  • Limit your core newsletter diet to a manageable selection
  • Read science fiction to explore plausible futures

One of the things that reading does, it helps you think better, but it also helps you write better.

Kip Bodnar · 03:00

Science fiction is a great way to understand where the world is going.

Kip Bodnar · 05:30
#marketing education#books#newsletters#learning
Tool04:00

Turn Twitter Bookmarks Into a Weekly Research Queue

Kip describes saving useful threads, stories, investment ideas, and marketing links into organized Twitter bookmark folders. Reviewing those bookmarks weekly prevents valuable material from disappearing in the speed of the feed.

  • Create bookmark folders for recurring research topics
  • Save valuable material when you cannot read it immediately
  • Review the saved material every week
  • Use the system to rediscover timely links and ideas

And I go and I go back and read those every week.

Kip Bodnar · 04:30

So using Twitter bookmarks as a way to get really good threads or rediscover awesome links to kind of current things is really awesome.

Kip Bodnar · 04:30
#twitter#research#learning system#bookmarks

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway19:00

Make Category Strategy Part of the Series A Story

The hosts discuss when a startup should define its category and conclude that the work should begin once there is credible market validation. Ideally, the resulting category narrative becomes part of the Series A pitch rather than being invented after investors have already committed.

  • Validate that customers want the product before formalizing the category
  • Involve the founder, marketing leader, and product leader
  • Connect category choices to product and business-model strategy
  • Use the Series A narrative to sell investors into the long-term vision

But it's a product, a business model, and a messaging strategy that's all coming together.

Kip Bodnar · 19:30

I think if you were drawing up a picture perfect, the outcome of this would be your pitch deck for your series A, if we're…

Kip Bodnar · 21:00
#category design#series a#fundraising#startup strategy
Takeaway22:30

Position Around a Different Problem, Not Inferior Competitors

Kip says compelling category narratives should not merely claim that competitors are bad. Instead, a company should acknowledge formidable rivals while arguing that market change has made their chosen problems less relevant than a new set of problems.

  • Avoid simplistic claims that every competitor is incompetent
  • Explain why the existing approach is no longer sufficient
  • Identify the more important problem created by market change
  • Invite customers and investors to choose between competing perspectives

Is what this whole exercise should be is an articulation not of why your competitors are crap, right? But why what they are doing no…

Kip Bodnar · 22:30

It is we have a difference of perspective.

Kip Bodnar · 23:30
#positioning#competition#category narrative#messaging
Takeaway24:30

Pair One Distinctive Strategic Bet With Excellent Execution

The hosts argue that a company does not need every marketing activity to be unconventional. It needs at least one meaningful, well-funded strategic difference while executing conventional tactics as well as or better than competitors.

  • Identify one strategy competitors are not pursuing
  • Commit meaningful time, money, and effort to the differentiated bet
  • Continue executing necessary conventional tactics
  • Avoid copying competitors across the entire marketing mix

The problem that I see it's most of the companies I talk to, they're doing everything everybody's doing with nothing different.

Kip Bodnar · 25:00

It's like, oh, what is the one thing about my strategy that I'm betting a lot of time and effort and money on that is…

Kip Bodnar · 25:30
#differentiation#marketing strategy#execution#strategic bets