02 January 2024

How To Build A $20k/month Community Business (Beginner’s Guide)

2Frameworks

10Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Strategy5 steps

Persona-Plus-Milestone Community Positioning

Unite a specific group around a concrete outcome they want to achieve

Read →

Marketing5 steps

TRIBE Framework

Test whether a product creates a real community rather than an audience

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster32:00

Why Hockey-Stick Growth Can Kill a Community

Community businesses should not be scaled like software products fueled by unlimited acquisition. Greg compares them to plants that need daily care, while the hosts describe a marketplace-like balance between growth and quality; linear growth may be healthier until the experience can absorb more members.

Hockey-stick membership growth can reduce quality
Community growth requires continuous care
Linear growth can be strategically correct
Adjacent products can scale faster if they do not damage the core experience

“you should be sprinkling gasoline not throwing it”
Greg Eisenberg · 32:30

“a community based business isn't a fire it's a plant that you water daily”
Greg Eisenberg · 33:00

#growth#community-health#quality#scaling

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take16:00

AI Will Homogenize Brands and Increase the Value of Community

Greg predicts that widespread use of the same generative tools will flood the market with content that looks and feels similar. Brands with distinctive cultures, identities, and member relationships will have a stronger defense against this commoditization.

Shared AI tools can produce similar brand output
Content volume will increase dramatically
Generic brands will become harder to distinguish
Community culture can create durable differentiation

“I think that AI is going to ex is basically going to kill so many different brands and it's going to level up so many…”
Greg Eisenberg · 16:00

“a lot of these brands are all going to look and feel the same”
Greg Eisenberg · 16:30

#ai#branding#differentiation#community

Hot Take29:00

The Two Marketing Plays: Make It Free or Make It Scarce

Greg argues that scarcity is particularly powerful for community businesses because restricted access can intensify desire and make acceptance feel meaningful. Kieran adds that operators must still understand member motivations well enough to sell the value of overcoming admission friction.

Restricted access can increase desire
Application friction makes acceptance meaningful
Free communities may struggle to feel distinctive
The promised value must justify every barrier

“if you want someone to want something tell them they can't have it”
Greg Eisenberg · 29:00

“the two there's two plays in marketing make it free or make it scarce”
Host · 29:30

#scarcity#marketing#applications#demand

Explainer· 1

Explainer07:30

When More Members Make an Exclusive Community Worse

Soho House demonstrates that communities can experience negative network effects after exceeding their ideal density. Demand and revenue may rise while queues, crowding, and indiscriminate admissions degrade the experience that made membership desirable.

Community value does not always increase with membership
Excess demand can reduce experience quality
Exclusivity supports aspiration and member relevance
Growth must preserve the original membership experience

“it's not an exponential the more people doesn't make it better”
Greg Eisenberg · 09:00

“they want to charge members $5,000 a year and they've got a lot of demand and they're letting everyone in but it's making the experience…”
Greg Eisenberg · 08:30

#exclusivity#network-effects#soho-house#membership

Story· 2

Story25:00

How a Paid Community Reached $20,000 a Month

Greg launched a private community for people building community-based products and priced it at $99 per month. He reports that it reached roughly $20,000 in monthly revenue with little marketing, illustrating the SaaS-like economics possible without building a conventional software product.

Paid communities can generate recurring revenue
A bundled tool can strengthen the membership offer
A narrow topic can support a meaningful business
Low technical overhead can create substantial enterprise value

“it's sass like Revenue without building any sass”
Greg Eisenberg · 25:00

“I think it brings in like $20,000 a month of of Revenue”
Greg Eisenberg · 27:00

#paid-community#recurring-revenue#membership#entrepreneurship

Story26:00

The Accountability Ritual Born in a Montreal Winter

Greg and author Julian Smith met at 7:00 every Monday morning to verify whether each had completed the prior week's commitments. They called it the punch you in the face meeting because reaching the coffee shop through deep Montreal snow imposed real effort and reinforced accountability.

The meeting happened at a fixed weekly time
Each participant reviewed the other's commitments
Environmental friction made the ritual memorable
The format was later adapted for a paid founder community

“we set up a meeting at 700 a.m. every single Monday where he would ask me did you complete”
Greg Eisenberg · 26:00

“we did it to for that accountability”
Greg Eisenberg · 26:30

#accountability#rituals#founders#habits

Takeaway· 4

Takeaway06:00

Why Physical Events Have New Community-Building Advantages

Digital spaces are easy to launch, but Greg argues that post-COVID founders have an underused opportunity in physical events. In-person gatherings restore the direct social contact that broadcast platforms and mega-scale internet audiences cannot reproduce.

Every community needs a shared space
The space can be digital or physical
In-person events help members form direct relationships
Broadcast social media is less natural than small-group gathering

“I actually think there's a huge huge amount of alpha right now postco to create just events really to bring people together and have people…”
Greg Eisenberg · 06:00

#events#community#belonging#in-person

Takeaway13:30

Why Selective Admission Can Improve the Member Experience

The Studio 54 and Soho House examples show how strict admission standards can protect what happens inside a community. Selectivity concentrates relevant members and makes access meaningful, but the resulting experience must justify the barrier.

Admission standards shape community composition
Scarcity can increase perceived value
Exclusivity must protect a genuinely better experience
Open access can make an aspirational club less compelling

“Studio 54 is a dictatorship at at the door but a democracy on the dance floor”
Greg Eisenberg · 13:30

“if it wasn't a dictatorship at the door and anyone could join then it becomes a lot less interesting for people to join”
Greg Eisenberg · 13:30

#admissions#scarcity#exclusivity#culture

Takeaway22:30

Build the Community Others Copy Through Constant Experimentation

Community concepts and rituals can be copied, so no successful activity remains defensible forever. Greg recommends building a culture of experimentation that generates unusual ideas faster than competitors can imitate them.

Successful rituals attract imitation
Community operators need a continuous idea pipeline
Experiments should be designed around audience resonance
Speed of cultural innovation can become a moat

“you need to be constantly throwing out really crazy ideas that you think will resonate with your audience and build a culture of experimentation”
Greg Eisenberg · 23:00

“you're constantly building new ideas faster than other people”
Greg Eisenberg · 23:00

#experimentation#moats#rituals#innovation

Takeaway30:30

Recruit the First 50 Members Before Opening the Doors

A strong community can begin with a deliberately recruited seed group whose members already create value for one another. This initial center of gravity makes later applicants want access while establishing the standards and interpersonal culture that future members encounter.

Early members define the culture
The seed group should be valuable on its own
Credible members increase demand from later applicants
Every new member should fit the intended experience

“I've went out and I've gotten 50 amazing people and if just the 51 of us just hung out we would have the best most…”
Host · 30:30

“the way to do that is by seeding properly in the beginning”
Greg Eisenberg · 32:00

#community-launch#recruiting#culture#membership