MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
12 September 2023

How To Guarantee AI Won’t Replace You (#155)

9Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 4

Hot Take08:00

The Next Marketer Combines Art, Science, and AI Tools

Internet-era marketing joined creativity with measurement and technical analysis. The next evolution adds practical command of AI tools, creating a hybrid marketer who can originate ideas, evaluate evidence, and automate or augment execution.

  • Traditional marketing depended heavily on creativity
  • The internet added data and scientific analysis
  • AI tools form the third core capability
  • Teams need strength across all three disciplines

Marketing really shifted to be at the intersection of creativity and science, right?

Kieran · 08:30

So it will live at the intersection of art, science, and wait for it, AI tools, right?

Kieran · 09:00
#marketing-skills#creativity#analytics#ai-tools
Hot Take14:30

AI-Generated Content Will Create a Sea of Sameness

As AI lowers the cost of producing content, overall output will increase while more material draws from the same underlying models and source patterns. The hosts argue that recognizable human personality will therefore become a stronger source of differentiation for brands.

  • AI makes content production easier
  • Greater output may amplify similarity
  • Shared model training encourages repetitive content
  • Distinct personalities can make brands recognizable

it's gonna kind of be a sea of sameness.

Kipp · 15:00

the way to really create truly differentiated content and build a differentiated brand is through personality.

Kipp · 15:00
#content-marketing#differentiation#brand#ai-content
Hot Take19:30

AI Will Punish Lazy Marketers and Reward Original Thinkers

AI can reproduce and remix established material more efficiently than marketers whose work consists mainly of copying existing tactics. That makes original thinking, clear writing, and a distinctive creator identity more economically valuable as generic execution becomes automated.

  • AI outperforms weak copy-and-paste execution
  • Generic marketers face increasing replacement pressure
  • Original thinkers become more important
  • Writing remains essential for expressing novel ideas

The lazy marketer is cooked because AI just does a better job.

Kipp · 20:00

It does not do the original thought part very well at all.

Kieran · 21:30
#original-thinking#writing#marketing-careers#creators
Hot Take26:30

AI Will Expand Marketing’s Ownership of the Customer Journey

As AI makes purchasing, onboarding, and support increasingly touchless, conventional boundaries between marketing, sales, and customer success may blur. The hosts predict that marketing will influence more of the end-to-end customer journey and become responsible for a larger share of revenue.

  • AI can assist purchasing and onboarding
  • Customer support will become more automated
  • Functional handoffs may blur
  • Marketing may own more customer experience and revenue

AI is gonna actually be able to help you buy a product, help you onboard to a product, help you to do customer support.

Kieran · 27:00

I think marketing own way more of the customer journey in the future.

Kieran · 27:00
#customer-journey#revenue#marketing#automation

Explainer· 3

Explainer01:00

AI Chat Is Becoming a Major Content-Consumption Channel

AI chat is presented as a new content category rather than merely another software feature. Rapid adoption across ChatGPT, Bard, Character.ai, and Snap suggests that marketers will increasingly need to reach audiences through conversational interfaces.

  • AI chat represents a distinct content category
  • Multiple platforms have attracted substantial audiences
  • Conversational interfaces may reshape content discovery
  • Marketers must prepare for changing audience behavior

AI has come along, and now we have this category of AI chat.

Kieran · 01:00

But there are many other instances where people are now going to consume content through AI chat.

Kieran · 01:30
#ai-chat#content-discovery#marketing#platform-shifts
Explainer12:30

An AI Concierge Can Shorten a Customer’s Time to Value

An AI concierge can analyze successful customer behavior and guide new users toward the actions most likely to produce value. The concept extends across signup, activation, onboarding, conversion, and ongoing product use, making more of the go-to-market journey touchless and personalized.

  • Many users abandon products before experiencing their value
  • The concierge learns from successful customer behavior
  • Guidance can continue throughout the customer lifecycle
  • Personalized assistance can improve activation and adoption

An AI concierge can shortcut that route to that value, right?

Kieran · 13:00

It can start to actually be your assistant to guide you through that process.

Kieran · 13:00
#ai-concierge#onboarding#product-led-growth#customer-success
Explainer24:00

Creator Channels Trade Off Distribution and Monetization

Creator platforms differ in how easily they distribute content and how effectively attention can be converted into revenue. Google and YouTube can perform well on both dimensions, while short-form video may build connection without offering equally strong monetization or subscriber conversion.

  • Evaluate channels by distribution and monetization
  • Few platforms perform strongly on both dimensions
  • Short-form video can build connection but be difficult to monetize
  • LinkedIn may become increasingly important for B2B creators

think about a channel that has high distribution or low distribution, which means it's easy to get your message out, or it's really hard to…

Kipp · 24:00

Short form video, for example, it's really valuable for building a connection, but it's super hard to monetize.

Kipp · 24:30
#distribution#monetization#creator-economy#channels

Story· 3

Story09:30

HubSpot Used AI to Answer 78% of Support Questions

HubSpot evaluated numerous AI possibilities, prioritized a small number of high-value use cases, and selected customer chat as an early implementation. An integration involving HubSpot Conversations, Google Dialogflow, and OpenAI reportedly answered most support questions while sharply increasing customer satisfaction.

  • The team initially identified 126 possible AI use cases
  • It narrowed the list to three priorities
  • Customer chat became the first implementation
  • AI answered 78% of support questions
  • Customer satisfaction increased substantially

we were able to fine-tune the open AI model enough to basically answer 78% of support questions via AI.

Kipp · 10:30

Customer satisfaction went up almost 300%.

Kipp · 11:00
#hubspot#customer-support#chatbots#case-study
Story11:00

Zapier Used Hackathons to Make AI Adoption Bottom-Up

Zapier encouraged teams to discover their own AI applications through company hackathons rather than relying only on executive mandates. The approach helped embed experimentation into the culture and led many employees to automate portions of their work using Zapier, OpenAI, and related tools.

  • AI adoption should combine top-down direction with bottom-up discovery
  • Hackathons let teams identify relevant use cases
  • Cultural participation matters alongside technical deployment
  • Employees used automation to change their own workflows

I think AI needs to be somehow top down and bottoms up.

Kieran · 11:00

over 45% of people within the company are actually automating parts of their job through Zapier and OpenAI and different AI tools.

Kieran · 11:30
#zapier#hackathons#culture#automation
Story22:00

Great Creators Kill Weak Ideas Without Sentimentality

A high-performing creator described treating content as an entrepreneurial testing process rather than protecting every idea. Concepts are shipped, measured through audience-retention and click-through data, and abandoned after repeated weak signals, while long-term creators accept years of failed attempts before a breakthrough.

  • Ship ideas instead of becoming attached to them
  • Use retention and click-through metrics as evidence
  • Terminate concepts that repeatedly underperform
  • Expect repeated failure while building content expertise
  • Combine data-driven iteration with original thought

I look at the data I have ideas I have no preciousness about my ideas.

Kipp · 22:30

If I have three bad metrics, you know, if the view duration isn't good enough, if the CTR on the thumbnail isn't good enough, that…

Kipp · 22:30
#content-creation#experimentation#analytics#youtube

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway02:30

Treat AI Disruption as an Opportunity to Gain Leverage

The hosts acknowledge that AI could automate a substantial portion of many jobs, but reject a purely defensive response. Marketers who learn to integrate AI can use the same disruption threatening established workflows to gain an advantage over slower peers.

  • Many job tasks may become automatable
  • Disruption creates both winners and losers
  • AI integration can create professional leverage
  • A defensive response sacrifices emerging opportunities

over two-thirds of every job will be automatable.

Kieran · 02:30

markers who can integrate AI in the way that we are gonna tell you, are gonna sit proudly on their winners podium.

Kieran · 03:00
#automation#career#ai-adoption#leverage
Takeaway07:00

AI Gives Fast Learners a Temporary Level Playing Field

Because the current AI transformation is new to most business professionals, established experience offers less protection than it does in mature disciplines. Someone who learns only months ahead of peers can develop an unusually large advantage while knowledge remains unevenly distributed.

  • Most businesspeople began the AI shift near the same starting line
  • Deep historical expertise is relatively rare
  • Small foresight advantages can produce outsized returns
  • Learning speed matters during technological transitions

if you just see just a little bit, just a tiny bit, months or a year into the future, you have an inordinate advantage over…

Kipp · 07:00

So if I can just learn faster than everybody else, I could be successful.

Kipp · 07:30
#learning#first-mover#ai-skills#career-growth