MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
03 December 2024

How to Win at Search When AI is Changing Everything

10Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster14:30

Google's Decline May Be Much Slower Than Tech Insiders Expect

The hosts describe replacing many Google searches with AI, but Simmons cautions that technology insiders overestimate how broadly this behavior has spread. Google's scale, default placement, and mainstream familiarity mean that meaningful decline in usage and clicks may unfold gradually rather than overnight.

  • Technology circles are not representative of mainstream search behavior.
  • Google still receives enormous monthly traffic.
  • Default browsers and homepages reinforce established habits.
  • Search usage and click-through rates can decline at different speeds.

I think we are in somewhat of a bubble in tech where we overestimate how many people have already changed their search behaviors.

Ross Simmons · 14:30

I still think we are very, very early.

Ross Simmons · 16:00
#google#search-behavior#ai-search#adoption

Hot Take· 3

Hot Take03:00

Why Mediocre AI Content Will Not Win Search

Ross Simmons argues that publishing generic LLM output is no longer a viable search strategy. Google can answer the same basic questions through AI overviews, so brands must differentiate through genuine experience, expertise, authority, trustworthiness, and editorial quality.

  • Generic AI output is unlikely to rank consistently.
  • AI overviews already address many basic informational queries.
  • Strong authorship and demonstrated expertise help distinguish content.
  • AI should augment human quality rather than replace it.

mediocrity in AI generated content as it comes out of the LLMs, probably isn't going to be sufficient enough for you to rank in the…

Ross Simmons · 03:00

We have to go back to fundamentals. We have to recognize that the old way doesn't work.

Ross Simmons · 03:30
#seo#ai-content#google#content-quality
Hot Take09:00

Written Content Still Deserves Half of a Growth Marketer's Time

Despite the rise of video and audio, Simmons says the internet remains fundamentally dependent on written language. He recommends treating writing broadly, including blog posts, social posts, newsletters, Reddit contributions, and lead-nurture campaigns that can later be repurposed.

  • Written language still supports discovery across media formats.
  • Writing includes more than conventional SEO blog posts.
  • Text can become the source material for repurposed assets.
  • Not every founder or marketer is naturally suited to video or audio.

the internet is still foundationally built on the back of written word.

Ross Simmons · 09:00

50% of written content is still very valuable.

Ross Simmons · 10:00
#writing#content-marketing#repurposing#growth
Hot Take25:30

Publishing Is the Beginning, Not the End

Many marketers stop once an optimized article goes live, but Simmons argues that publication should trigger a broader distribution effort. Foundation's distribution.ai product turns a source article into native assets for Reddit, X, LinkedIn, carousels, and video so one investment can reach multiple audiences.

  • A finished article should become source material for more assets.
  • Each channel needs a format native to its audience.
  • Distribution diversifies traffic beyond Google.
  • The channel mix must evolve as platform opportunities change.

You press publish, now it's time to distribute that content.

Ross Simmons · 25:30

you ingest your blog posts, and from that becomes a lot of multimedia assets that go into Reddit, multimedia assets that go out onto X,…

Ross Simmons · 26:00
#distribution#repurposing#multichannel#content-marketing

Explainer· 3

Explainer05:00

How Content Debt Quietly Erodes Organic Traffic

A large content library can become a liability when previously successful pages grow outdated. Simmons calls this content debt and recommends using AI to help human editors refresh older assets faster while preserving high editorial standards.

  • Older content can decline as audience expectations change.
  • A strong article from 2016 may be mediocre by current standards.
  • AI can accelerate updates without removing human oversight.
  • Existing high-value pages may deserve attention before new production.

Over the years of creating content, you build up a library, but some of that content in the library is outdated.

Ross Simmons · 05:00

now with AI, we can augment the human to optimize these pieces to still make them excellent and great at a faster rate.

Ross Simmons · 05:30
#content-debt#content-refresh#seo#editorial
Explainer17:00

What Makes Content More Visible to Generative Engines

Simmons describes research into generative engine optimization, where content structure and credibility can affect whether LLMs use or cite a source. Clear writing, authoritative language, technical relevance, quotations, statistics, and citations overlap substantially with established high-quality SEO practices.

  • LLMs can be influenced by how information is presented online.
  • Clear and fluent content is easier for systems to interpret.
  • Technical terms establish relevance within a niche.
  • Sources, quotations, and statistics strengthen authority.
  • Distribution to licensed data sources may improve visibility.

There's this concept of generative engine optimization.

Ross Simmons · 17:00

You use technical terms that are related to your niche, it was fluent. You cited sources, you had quotations and stats that you would actually…

Ross Simmons · 18:00
#geo#llm#seo#citations#authority
Explainer19:30

Inside an AI-Assisted Historical Content Refresh

The Foundation team prioritizes declining pages that once earned traffic and backlinks, then compares them with current search results. Editors use tools such as Frase, the Wayback Machine, ChatGPT, Claude, and HeyGen to identify gaps, strengthen introductions, add evidence and multimedia, update internal links, and produce tangible resources.

  • Start with pages showing traffic decline but retaining valuable backlinks.
  • Compare the page against current search-result competitors.
  • Use historical snapshots to study how winning pages evolved.
  • Add credible sources, statistics, quotations, multimedia, and current links.
  • Keep a human editor responsible for final quality.

the first thing that we do is we look at um trends around our traffic. And what we're looking for are any pieces that have…

Ross Simmons · 19:30

we're having a human that is augmented with AI to go through a series of checklists that we create around how to improve these pieces.

Ross Simmons · 20:30
#content-optimization#seo#ai-tools#historical-content

Story· 1

Story31:30

When Ross Simmons's Own Mother Misidentified His AI Avatar

Simmons tested a real recording against a HeyGen avatar saying the same words, and even close colleagues and family members selected the wrong version. The experience prompted him and his mother to establish a secret verification code for suspicious voice calls, illustrating both the quality and risks of synthetic media.

  • Modern avatars can fool people who know the subject personally.
  • Visible glitches have become less frequent as models improve.
  • Synthetic voice and video increase impersonation risks.
  • Families may need an independent verification method.

My assistant got it wrong. My colleagues got it wrong. My own mom got it wrong.

Ross Simmons · 32:00

Mom, if somebody calls you with my voice, hang up and call me back. And there's a secret code that you have to say.

Ross Simmons · 32:30
#heygen#deepfakes#synthetic-media#security

Tool· 1

Tool22:00

Use AI to Add Tangible Utility to B2B Articles

Simmons suggests asking ChatGPT to propose a template, guide, resource, or asset that would make an article more useful. A selected idea can then be converted into a spreadsheet, formatted, and offered alongside the content to create a stronger reader outcome.

  • Ask AI for several utility-driven companion assets.
  • Choose a resource directly connected to the article's subject.
  • Convert the idea into a usable spreadsheet or template.
  • Apply human formatting and design before publication.

We give away something tactical and very like tangible, utility-driven in B2B.

Ross Simmons · 22:00

Please give me four ideas on a tangible template guide, resource, or asset that I could give someone to make this piece even better.

Ross Simmons · 22:30
#chatgpt#b2b-content#templates#lead-magnets

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway06:30

Why Early-Stage Companies Should Take Reddit Seriously

Startups without strong domain authority can reach precisely defined audiences through relevant subreddits. Reddit content can also gain visibility through Google and influence LLM responses, but participation must add native community value rather than function as empty promotion.

  • Subreddit membership naturally identifies audience interests.
  • Google increasingly surfaces Reddit discussions in search results.
  • Brands can answer Reddit threads already ranking for priority queries.
  • Useful contributions can earn upvotes and referral traffic.

If you're early stage, Reddit is a massive play.

Ross Simmons · 07:00

Answer the queries that are already ranking in Reddit for your various keywords, and then get yourself some upvotes because you add value to the…

Ross Simmons · 08:00
#reddit#startups#distribution#seo#community
Takeaway10:30

LinkedIn's Video Incentives Create a B2B Attention Opportunity

LinkedIn wants video to retain attention and expand advertising opportunities, creating favorable distribution for B2B creators. Simmons points to a 30-second video that generated roughly 400,000 views as evidence that founders should test the format while the platform is incentivizing it.

  • LinkedIn benefits financially when video increases time on platform.
  • The platform is investing in video creators and courses.
  • Short B2B videos can receive unusually broad reach.
  • Creators should study platform incentives before selecting formats.

If I'm a founder in B2B, then there's no question that video is going to be at play.

Ross Simmons · 10:30

We put out a video the other day and it had like 400,000 views, and it was like a video that was 30 seconds.

Ross Simmons · 11:00
#linkedin#video#b2b#attention
Takeaway34:30

AI Amplifies Skill but Cannot Replace Domain Expertise

The episode closes by framing AI as leverage for people who already understand their craft. A strong writer can work faster and produce more with AI, while a weak writer still lacks the judgment needed to recognize or improve poor output.

  • AI tools augment rather than eliminate foundational skills.
  • Expert users extract more value from the same tool.
  • Weak practitioners still need to learn their discipline.
  • Domain expertise becomes more valuable as production leverage increases.

if you are a great writer, using AI makes you a greater writer faster.

Ross Simmons · 34:30

the tool can give everyone value, but the value is really connected to the talents behind it.

Ross Simmons · 35:00
#domain-expertise#writing#ai-tools#skills