MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
12 June 2025

I Tested 5 AI Prompts That Replace Weeks of Creative Work

10Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster02:00

Creative Ideas Do Not Have to Arrive by Accident

Jason Keith challenges the belief that creativity is an innate gift or a flash of inspiration. He argues that people can improve by defining, testing, and refining a personal creative process.

  • Creativity can be developed rather than merely inherited.
  • A process makes creative behavior testable and repeatable.
  • Different people can build different effective processes.

I think we were taught growing up that just like creative ideas come to us.

Jason Keith · 02:00

to get better at something, you really have to define a process for it.

Jason Keith · 02:00
#creativity#creative process#learning
Myth Buster04:00

The Solo Creator Is a Myth

Even apparently solitary creative work depends on collaborators somewhere in the process. Readers, publishers, customers, teammates, or AI systems can all supply feedback and shape the eventual output.

  • Creative work usually has an upstream or downstream collaborator.
  • Customers participate by reacting to and shaping products.
  • AI can provide collaboration when a human team is unavailable.

I think understanding that like the solo creator concept is a myth.

Jason Keith · 04:00

So there's always a collaboration point in front or behind you, and just realizing when you need to break out of solo work and when…

Jason Keith · 04:00
#collaboration#solo creators#ai

Explainer· 2

Explainer22:00

Great Creative Work Lives in the Iteration

The discussion separates ideation, which generates many starting points, from iteration, which repeatedly improves selected ideas. AI is valuable on both sides because it makes numerous revision rounds faster and less laborious.

  • Ideation expands the pool of possible directions.
  • Iteration develops promising ideas into remarkable work.
  • Creators and artists may perform dozens of revision rounds.
  • AI lowers the cost and effort of repeated revision.

there's two ways to scale ideas. There's ideation and iteration.

Jason Keith · 22:00

going like 10, 20, 30 rounds of iteration, that's where like creators and artists really live.

Jason Keith · 22:30
#iteration#ideation#creative quality#ai
Explainer32:00

Bad Campaign Ideas Range From Obvious to Absurd

The campaign discussion defines bad ideas along a spectrum from boringly obvious to wildly absurd. Their purpose is to challenge assumptions and provoke safer, workable remixes rather than secure immediate executive approval.

  • Obvious and absurd ideas expose different assumptions.
  • Risky concepts can function as thought starters.
  • A wild idea can be remixed into an approvable version.
  • Initial ideation benefits from temporarily widening acceptable risk.

The two core ways are obvious ideas and absurd ideas.

Jason Keith · 32:00

all of these are meant again to widen your thinking and to take a few more risk within your kind of initial ideation process.

Jason Keith · 34:00
#campaigns#assumptions#contrarian thinking#marketing

Story· 2

Story05:00

The Rolling Suitcase Came From Expertise Meeting Experience

Keith explains that walks, travel, chores, and other experiences can create the incubation and inputs needed for insight. The rolling suitcase illustrates how relevant expertise can collide with a personally experienced problem to produce an invention.

  • Meditative activities give ideas time to incubate.
  • Richer life experiences provide more creative inputs.
  • Breakthroughs can occur where expertise overlaps with lived pain.

Meditative task is how I define that, like taking a walk, taking a shower, doing the dishes.

Jason Keith · 05:00

he worked at a luggage company, so he had this expertise that matches up against the life experience, and that's where we make those collisions…

Jason Keith · 05:30
#incubation#invention#life experience#insight
Story14:00

AI Compressed a Two-Month Naming Exercise Into an Hour

Kip and Keith compare a conventional rebrand involving roughly a thousand candidate names with an AI-assisted naming session. The traditional effort consumed dozens of hours across two months, while AI produced a viable shortlist in about an hour without eliminating the need for customer research.

  • Serious naming exercises may consider around a thousand candidates.
  • Rapid AI generation reduces early-stage production time.
  • Human feedback and customer research still validate the shortlist.
  • Faster generation does not require accepting lower-quality names.

the last rebrand I did, we probably spent, I would say 40 hours to get to a thousand names.

Jason Keith · 14:00

That was over two months.

Jason Keith · 14:30
#naming#branding#time savings#ai

Tool· 1

Tool37:00

Use Quick Audience Research to Test Creative Options

Creative confidence should be paired with direct audience evidence. Keith recommends showing multiple options to relevant customers or prospects through lightweight channels, observing their preferences, and repeating the research over multiple rounds.

  • Generate several options before asking for audience input.
  • Test with people who resemble actual customers.
  • Use practical channels such as DMs or email lists.
  • Run more than one feedback round when possible.

literally just running it by customer service leadership people out there in the wild that either are customers or could be customers

Jason Keith · 37:00

those iterative feedback pieces are really important and doing multiple rounds of it is even better.

Jason Keith · 37:00
#audience research#validation#customer feedback#testing

Takeaway· 5

Takeaway03:30

Why Bad Ideas Can Unlock Better Ones

Bad ideas are presented as a way to escape the narrow mental box people typically bring to a problem. Their value is not necessarily in execution but in expanding the range of connections and possibilities under consideration.

  • Initial creative thinking often begins inside a narrow box.
  • Bad ideas interrupt conventional assumptions.
  • Broader exploration can reveal useful connections faster.

bad ideas, I say are the shortcut to creativity.

Jason Keith · 03:30

When you start with creative thinking, you typically start in a small box, and bad ideas and a lot of other things in this book…

Jason Keith · 03:30
#bad ideas#brainstorming#creative thinking
Takeaway16:30

Move Fast and Ugly Before You Refine

The messy-first approach gives creators permission to generate imperfect material without mistaking it for the final product. Speed protects momentum, while later human refinement turns promising fragments into polished work.

  • Do not treat the first output as the final product.
  • Momentum matters more than immediate polish.
  • An imperfect draft can contain the seed of a stronger direction.
  • Separate generation from editing.

speed isn't as important as momentum.

Jason Keith · 16:30

the messy perspective gives you permission to just not accept these as a final product, understand this is like a working process

Jason Keith · 16:30
#drafting#momentum#writing#iteration
Takeaway21:00

A Creative Prompt Should Continue After Its First Answer

Keith argues that many AI prompts fail because they define only a single question-and-answer exchange. Feedback loops, follow-up questions, and explicit next actions turn a one-shot response into a creative working process.

  • One-shot prompts stop before meaningful refinement begins.
  • Prompts should specify what happens after the initial output.
  • Feedback loops improve later rounds.
  • Structured follow-up makes creative work easier to repeat.

Something I see with a lot of AI prompts is it's just a question and answer. They don't really define a step two.

Jason Keith · 21:00

whether it's a feedback loop or questions asked, I think that's an important step.

Jason Keith · 21:30
#prompting#feedback loops#ai#creative process
Takeaway27:00

Combine a Strong Prompt With Rich Context

Generic brainstorming requests often produce mediocre ideas because the model lacks direction and relevant information. Strong instructions can help on their own, but customer personas, brand guidance, prior work, research, and performance data can make the output substantially more useful.

  • Weak prompts often yield generic brainstorming results.
  • Detailed context grounds ideas in the customer and market.
  • Brand guides and past content help align the output.
  • Real-world performance data can improve later rounds.

what I have found is that you either have to give it a great prompt or great context to get a solid answer.

Kip · 27:30

if you have other knowledge blocks like customer persona, brand guide examples of content you've already produced.

Jason Keith · 28:00
#context#prompt engineering#brainstorming#marketing
Takeaway35:30

Treat Play as an Investment in Creative Taste

Keith describes play as judgment-free creative practice that strengthens taste, confidence, and exposure to new inputs. Because play is personal, it may involve art, languages, hobbies, travel, research, games, or time with interesting people.

  • Personal taste supports confident creative decisions.
  • Play provides creative practice without outcome pressure.
  • Useful play differs from person to person.
  • Activities outside professional expertise create fresh inputs.
  • Play should be treated as an investment rather than a luxury.

play is not the opposite of work, it's the opposite of depression.

Jason Keith · 36:00

play is the practice of creativity, you know, without any judgment, right?

Jason Keith · 36:00
#play#taste#creativity#self-development