MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
24 August 2022

Is a YouTube Subscriber The Most Valuable Subscriber on The Internet?

5Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 4

Hot Take00:30

Why a YouTube Subscriber May Be the Internet’s Most Valuable

YouTube subscribers can consume long-form video, Shorts, podcasts, product reviews, and audio-led content through one account. The hosts argue that this combination of formats, search, recommendations, and discovery makes a YouTube subscriber unusually valuable to creators and marketers.

  • One subscriber can follow multiple content formats
  • Shorts introduce audiences to new creators
  • Search and recommendations provide ongoing discovery
  • Podcast support increases the value of an existing channel audience

I'm going to argue that a YouTube subscriber is now the most valuable subscriber on the internet.

Kip Bodner · 00:30

I agree it is.

Kieran Flanagan · 02:30
#youtube#subscribers#podcasting#distribution
Hot Take05:30

Why YouTube May Make Background Audio Free

Kip predicts that YouTube will move background audio out of Premium so it can reach a larger podcast audience. He expects new podcast-specific premium features to replace it as an upgrade incentive.

  • Background playback is essential to audio consumption
  • A paywall limits YouTube's addressable podcast audience
  • YouTube could introduce new premium audio features
  • The predicted change could occur within twelve months

I think they are going to take background audio to free because they need to open up the audience for who can listen to podcasts.

Kip Bodner · 06:00

I think in the next 12 months, we will see YouTube drop background audio to the free version of YouTube and layer in some new…

Kip Bodner · 06:30
#youtube premium#background audio#product strategy#prediction
Hot Take08:00

YouTube’s Creator Economics Could Beat Traditional Streaming

Kieran argues that YouTube can compete with streaming companies without relying entirely on expensive original films and television. Revenue from its established creator and advertising business could subsidize expansion into premium programming.

  • YouTube is not dependent solely on costly original productions
  • Its existing business provides substantial revenue
  • That revenue can fund expansion into premium entertainment
  • The model may offer an advantage over conventional streamers

YouTube eats other streaming companies, like we wins the streaming battles.

Kieran Flanagan · 08:00

Because they have a revenue path that is not dependent upon high production movies and making their own high production TV shows

Kieran Flanagan · 08:00
#streaming#youtube#creator economy#business models
Hot Take17:00

Recommendation Algorithms May Reshape Podcast Guest Booking

The hosts predict that creators will choose guests and recurring segments partly for their ability to perform in YouTube recommendations. Editorial decisions could therefore become closely tied to discoverability and relationships between videos.

  • Guests may be selected for recommendation potential
  • Segments may be designed for algorithmic distribution
  • Related videos can connect appearances across shows
  • Early creators may discover and exploit effective formats

People are going to completely re-engineer their show format and guest strategy for YouTube recommendations.

Kip Bodner · 17:00

Guests are gonna get invited because they rank better in the recommendation algorithm.

Kip Bodner · 17:30
#recommendation algorithm#podcast guests#editorial strategy#youtube

Explainer· 4

Explainer03:00

How YouTube Search Could Fix Podcast Discovery

Traditional podcast discovery often depends on already knowing a show or its host. Podcast cards in YouTube search could instead surface individual episodes for evergreen queries, specific guests, and narrowly relevant subjects.

  • Existing podcast discovery favors known shows and hosts
  • Search cards can generate evergreen episode traffic
  • Listeners can find relevant one-off episodes
  • Guest and topic connections may improve cross-show discovery

Podcast cards in the search results pages. That is the game changer.

Kieran Flanagan · 04:00

What YouTube is going to do with those podcast search results is it make it much, much easier to find like one-off episodes of podcasts…

Kip Bodner · 05:00
#podcast discovery#youtube search#evergreen content#seo
Explainer12:30

Video-First Podcasts Will Create New Advertising Formats

As podcasts become visual products, sponsorships can move beyond conventional host-read audio spots. Brands may produce custom video creative for podcast placements, while unified analytics could provide a clearer picture of listening across platforms.

  • Visual shows support richer branded creative
  • Podcast sponsorships may receive custom video cut-downs
  • Audio ads will remain but formats could diversify
  • Integrated analytics may consolidate cross-platform reporting

The types of ads and sponsorships you see and have in podcasts are going to change.

Kip Bodner · 13:00

I think ad formats are gonna drastically change.

Kieran Flanagan · 14:00
#podcast advertising#video ads#sponsorships#analytics
Explainer15:30

YouTube Could Remove Friction From Paid Podcast Growth

YouTube advertising can target and retarget likely listeners while keeping discovery, playback, and subscription inside one platform. This reduces the app-switching and search friction that weakens conversion and retention in conventional podcast campaigns.

  • YouTube offers strong audience targeting
  • Listeners may subscribe without leaving the ad environment
  • A single platform reduces acquisition friction
  • Lower friction could improve conversion and retention

YouTube targeting is amazing.

Kip Bodner · 15:30

Well, when it all happens in one platform, it's way better, and you're gonna have way better conversion rates.

Kip Bodner · 16:00
#podcast growth#youtube ads#retargeting#conversion
Explainer18:30

YouTube Could Turn Podcasts Into an Interconnected Community

Because creation, reactions, recommendations, and playback occur inside one ecosystem, podcasts may increasingly respond to and promote one another. This could make shows more topical, collaborative, and embedded in YouTube’s internal culture.

  • Reaction videos help creators enter related-video feeds
  • Shows can respond directly to other shows
  • Topical participation strengthens ecosystem visibility
  • Creators outside YouTube culture risk being excluded

I think it collapses podcasts into a singular platform, and it's gonna be much more community-driven, and that podcast will start to speak to each…

Kieran Flanagan · 19:00

YouTube is the most insular culture of any of the platforms.

Kip Bodner · 19:30
#youtube culture#podcast community#related videos#creators

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway08:30

Podcasts Are Shifting From Audio-First to Video-First

The hosts expect creators to design shows for YouTube first and treat audio as a secondary output. They compare the shift to SlideShare changing how marketers designed presentations once visual, evergreen distribution became more valuable.

  • Creators will design podcast formats around video performance
  • Audio will remain useful as a secondary version
  • Visual storytelling will influence recording and production
  • Distribution incentives can reshape the underlying medium

YouTube first, audio second. YouTube first, audio second.

Kieran Flanagan · 10:00

So the way we actually start to create these shows will be much more visual in mind, but work secondary for audio.

Kieran Flanagan · 09:30
#video podcasts#content strategy#youtube#production
Takeaway11:30

Turn One YouTube-First Show Into Searchable Content Assets

A YouTube-first show can supply the full episode, audio, Shorts, and smaller keyword-focused videos. This makes the content strategy more coherent by concentrating production and audience growth on one discoverable platform.

  • Record one strong primary show
  • Extract Shorts for creator and episode discovery
  • Create smaller videos around individual search queries
  • Use the audio version on traditional podcast platforms
  • Concentrate subscriber growth on YouTube

how do I create one thing in a way where I can break it into all of the things that I can do to generate…

Kieran Flanagan · 12:00

We just bet on YouTube. We create incredible shows for YouTube.

Kieran Flanagan · 24:00
#content repurposing#youtube shorts#search strategy#podcasting
Takeaway18:00

Early YouTube Podcast Adopters Could Gain Outsized Reach

New platform features often receive extra algorithmic and promotional support while the platform works to establish them. The hosts believe podcasters who move early could gain considerably more leverage than those who wait one or two years.

  • Platforms often promote newly launched formats
  • Early adopters may receive stronger organic distribution
  • The highest-leverage window may last six to twelve months
  • Delayed adoption could mean competing in a more mature market

So the moving early on this YouTube podcast change is going to be important.

Kip Bodner · 18:00

And the first movers for those first six to twelve months are going to get way more leverage than the folks that don't get on…

Kip Bodner · 18:30
#early adopters#youtube podcasts#organic reach#platform strategy