MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
16 September 2025

The Brand NEW AI Marketing Strategy for 2025

1Frameworks
8Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster17:00

AEO Does Not Make the Heart of Good SEO Obsolete

Frost distinguishes enduring content quality from rapidly changing optimization mechanics. Useful educational content for a defined audience remains foundational, but AI engines reward substantially more specific material shaped around a persona, use case, and detailed question.

  • Quality educational content remains foundational
  • Optimization mechanics have changed dramatically
  • Broad ultimate guides are becoming less useful
  • AI conversations produce personalized and contextual answers
  • Content must target detailed persona and use-case combinations

the heart of good SEO if you were doing SEO well you were producing great content that was meant to educate and be valuable for…

Aja Frost · 17:30

It's very specific. It's persona and use case versus here's what this educational content could be for anyone.

Aja Frost · 19:30
#aeo#seo#content#search

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take05:00

AI Can Strengthen a Writer's Voice Instead of Replacing It

Frost explains that she creates the core ideas and language for her Substack before involving AI. She then uses AI and performance data to evaluate resonance, presenting the technology as an amplifier of distinctive human creativity rather than its source.

  • Create the core message before introducing AI
  • Identify language that could only come from the creator or brand
  • Use AI to evaluate likely audience resonance
  • Use historical performance data to refine packaging
  • Codified voice allows creativity to scale without becoming generic

the core content creation that I do, it's all me.

Aja Frost · 05:00

AI can build upon your own creativity, your own point of view, your own voice.

Aja Frost · 06:30
#writing#creativity#brand-voice#ai
Hot Take21:30

Brand Mentions Matter More Than Backlinks for AI Authority

The speakers argue that AI engines assess authority differently from conventional search engines. Mentions and recommendations on Reddit, LinkedIn, Quora, and customer communities can provide stronger recommendation signals than a backlink-focused strategy alone.

  • AI engines do not rely on backlinks in the same way as traditional search
  • Brand mentions act as credibility and authority signals
  • Customer advocacy can increase relevant mentions
  • Marketers should participate in forums where customers already gather
  • Community activity reaches both humans and AI systems

we're optimizing for brand mentions and not backlinks because AI engines do not care about backlinks as a measure of how credible or authoritative your…

Aja Frost · 21:30

You need to be active in in forums where your customers are and where AI engines are.

Aja Frost · 21:30
#brand-mentions#backlinks#communities#aeo

Explainer· 2

Explainer01:00

Why Traditional Marketing Channels Are Breaking at Once

The speakers describe a compounding channel crisis rather than a single search problem. Zero-click searches and AI interception reduce organic traffic, while marketers respond by increasing advertising and email volume, further raising costs and depressing engagement.

  • 58.5% of Google searches reportedly end without a click
  • AI is contributing to double-digit traffic declines
  • Reduced search traffic pushes companies toward more paid advertising
  • Higher email volume floods audiences and lowers performance
  • Alternative channels are becoming saturated and competitive

58.5% of Google searches are now ending without a click

Aja Frost · 01:00

Every other channel is getting saturated. They're getting more competitive.

Kip Bodnar · 01:30
#search#zero-click#advertising#email#ai
Explainer02:30

Why Linear Inbound Models No Longer Fit the Customer Journey

Traditional inbound marketing assumed comparatively simple businesses and customers progressing through predictable stages. Modern companies have more revenue streams and technology, while buyers jump among AI assistants, search tools, tabs, and other information sources before returning to a decision thread.

  • Earlier inbound models reflected simpler businesses
  • Even small companies now use sophisticated technology stacks
  • Customer journeys no longer progress in straight lines
  • AI assistants fragment research across multiple interfaces
  • Marketing systems must accommodate complexity and revisitation

people used to just move in straight lines and now we see they're doing all sorts of things.

Aja Frost · 03:30
#inbound#customer-journey#complexity#ai

Tool· 1

Tool24:30

Ask Campaign Data Questions in Natural Language

Bodnar recommends connecting marketing data to AI assistants so marketers can investigate campaigns by typing or speaking questions instead of manually navigating spreadsheets and dashboards. He also mentions Willow Voice as a dictation tool for accelerating this conversational workflow.

  • Connect CRM data to an AI assistant
  • Ask focused questions about individual campaigns and projects
  • Use voice dictation when typing becomes a bottleneck
  • Reduce dependence on manual dashboard exploration
  • Feed useful answers back into future marketing decisions

Can you ask the right questions without needing a big data analyst or having to comb through a spreadsheet or a dashboard to get unique…

Kip Bodnar · 25:00
#analytics#crm#voice#ai-assistants

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway20:00

Educational Content Must Teach AI When to Recommend Your Product

Generic educational content may improve an AI engine's answer without helping the company that published it. The speakers argue that useful information should deliberately explain how the company's product enables the desired outcome, especially in bottom-of-funnel situations.

  • Generic education can benefit AI engines without benefiting the publisher
  • Content should connect advice to a concrete product-enabled action
  • Bottom-of-funnel relevance matters even for educational topics
  • The product connection must be explicit enough for an AI engine to understand
  • Specific logistical guidance is more valuable than a generic listicle

if you just feed humans, well, if you feed AI engines that'll feed humans educational insights without tying it back to your product, the AI…

Aja Frost · 20:30
#content-marketing#aeo#recommendations#bottom-funnel
Takeaway22:30

AI Referral Visitors Converted at Three Times the Rate

HubSpot found that visitors arriving from AI engines converted at a much higher rate than other traffic. That observation led the company to expose AI referrals in its product and consider distinct landing-page experiences for these higher-intent visitors.

  • AI referral traffic grew from negligible to commercially material
  • HubSpot observed a threefold conversion rate
  • Referral-source visibility helps marketers isolate the audience
  • AI visitors may warrant different landing-page experiences
  • Conversion paths should reflect the higher apparent intent

a year ago, it was a decimal point of our traffic. Now, it's a material amount of our traffic and our revenue.

Kip Bodnar · 22:30

we saw that AI engine visitors were converting at 3x the rate

Aja Frost · 24:00
#ai-referrals#conversion#landing-pages#analytics