MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
14 November 2023

The Secret Growth Strategies Behind Spotify's Top Podcasts

14Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Innovation6 steps

AI Context Bank Workflow

Ground AI in source material and exemplars before asking it to draft or critique.

Read →
Marketing5 steps

Content Relationship Ladder

Match information and entertainment to the audience relationship each medium creates.

Read →
Productivity5 steps

Create-Do Acceleration Flywheel

Publish real work to generate feedback that motivates faster, deeper execution.

Read →
Communication5 steps

Depth-to-Articulation Compression

Study a subject's contours until you can express its hidden truth concisely.

Read →
Marketing5 steps

Feature Before Copy

Find the product truth customers value before polishing how you describe it.

Read →
Self-Mastery4 steps

Interesting Inputs, Interesting Outputs

Curate your days and information diet to produce more distinctive content.

Read →
Strategy4 steps

Method Over Niche

Build audience loyalty around how you think rather than one permanent topic.

Read →
Influence5 steps

Personality-to-Topic Flexibility Rule

Earn permission to broaden topics by increasing authentic audience intimacy.

Read →
Strategy5 steps

Podcast Video Investment Ladder

Choose a video-production tier by balancing added effort against expected impact.

Read →
Mindset4 steps

Point-of-View Feedback Filter

Hear broad feedback, then act only on signals consistent with informed conviction.

Read →
Innovation5 steps

Public Sketchpad Feedback Loop

Test ideas publicly before investing in larger pieces of content.

Read →
Innovation5 steps

Show, Don't Just Discuss

Turn abstract commentary into demonstrable experiences audiences can see and share.

Read →
Marketing6 steps

Trusted Podcast Distribution Loop

Borrow trust, seed ideas on discoverable platforms, and convert attention into listening.

Read →
Marketing5 steps

YouTube-First Podcast Rule

Design the visual version first when distribution and feedback are growth priorities.

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster07:30

Creators Do Not Have to Stay in One Topic Lane

Steph challenges the conventional advice that creators must remain tied to one niche. Over a long horizon, audiences can follow a creator across subjects when they connect with that creator's recognizable perspective, presentation style, and personality.

  • Develop a recognizable way of interpreting and packaging ideas
  • Let subject matter evolve alongside your interests and audience
  • Build affinity for the creator rather than dependence on one topic
  • Maintain a long time horizon instead of optimizing for temporary growth spurts

No, I actually don't think you need to stay in your lane.

Steph Smith · 07:30

what is more compelling is people adhering to the way you think.

Steph Smith · 08:00
#creator-economy#positioning#audience#personal-brand

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take43:00

Most Business and Tech Podcasts Are Too Lazy

Steph argues that many business and technology podcasts rely on prominent guests and publish minimally produced conversations. Competing genres such as true crime demonstrate that sound design, production, packaging, and experiential storytelling should be treated as core product features rather than optional polish.

  • Do more than book a prominent guest and publish the conversation
  • Invest in sound design and production quality
  • Create episodes that show technology rather than merely discussing it
  • Clarify the show's differentiated promise in one line
  • Treat each episode as a designed product

most just are quite lazy, quite frankly, from the perspective they're like, okay, let's just bring in big guests, which is great.

Steph Smith · 44:30

this is a product they're creating.

Steph Smith · 44:30
#podcast-production#business-podcasts#packaging#differentiation

Explainer· 3

Explainer04:00

Use Social Media as a Public Sketchbook for Ideas

Social platforms provide creators with a testing ground where unfinished ideas can receive immediate feedback. Unlike older publishing channels, modern platforms reveal what resonates before a creator invests in a larger article, episode, or project.

  • Publish early versions of ideas in public
  • Use audience responses to identify promising concepts
  • Test ideas across platforms such as Twitter and Reddit
  • Borrow inspiration from ideas that audiences have already validated

if you're going to make stuff, you have to have like a testing ground, you have to have a sketchpad.

Kip Bodnar · 04:00

you can not only test your own ideas, but you can also borrow other people's ideas that are pre-vetted.

Steph Smith · 05:00
#social-media#validation#feedback#content-testing
Explainer12:30

Deep Experience Makes Concise Content Possible

Clear writing is not merely a matter of prose technique. Steph argues that sustained experience gives creators a detailed understanding of a subject's contours, objections, and misunderstandings, allowing years of thought to be compressed into a concise and resonant statement.

  • Study or live a subject long enough to understand its nuances
  • Anticipate the audience's likely objections and misconceptions
  • Use accumulated experience to compress complex ideas
  • Develop the courage to articulate observations others avoid

if you've been studying something or living something for long enough, you understand all the contours and you understand the likely pushback or the likely…

Steph Smith · 13:30

you can kind of like take three years of thoughts and put it into, you know, 170 characters, right?

Steph Smith · 13:30
#expertise#writing#research#communication
Explainer26:00

Why Podcasts Behave More Like Best Friends Than Search Results

Steph contrasts the audience relationships created by blogs, newsletters, and podcasts. Articles are often transactional, newsletters resemble recurring coworker relationships, and podcasts create intimate, high-time-investment relationships that allow compelling hosts to cover a wider range of subjects.

  • Blog readers often seek one specific answer without caring about the author
  • Newsletter subscribers expect recurring informational value
  • Podcast listeners spend substantially more time with creators
  • Host affinity gives podcasts more freedom to evolve across topics
  • More personality exposure increases topical flexibility

podcasts are like your best friends, newsletters are like your coworkers, and then you know, blogs are more like some stranger you meet at a…

Steph Smith · 26:30

podcasts are actually the medium where I think you can constantly reinvent yourself if you are compelling enough as a person.

Steph Smith · 29:00
#podcasts#audience#media#creator-economy

Story· 1

Story16:00

How Public Feedback Accelerated Steph Smith's Building Speed

Creating in public can reinforce the underlying work by supplying motivation and accountability. Steph describes progressing from six months of learning to code, to a one-month challenge, and then to a 24-hour startup challenge after positive public feedback encouraged her to build faster.

  • Public creation can increase motivation to continue the underlying work
  • Positive feedback can shorten the time between projects
  • Building and publishing can form a mutually reinforcing loop
  • The loop works best when the content reflects work the creator genuinely values

because I create about it, I want to do it more.

Kip Bodnar · 16:00

I spent uh what, like six months or so learning before I built like shipped my first thing on product hunt. Then I got so…

Steph Smith · 16:30
#building-in-public#motivation#coding#creator-loop

Tool· 1

Tool19:00

Use AI to Clarify Ideas, Improve Questions, and Mine Customer Language

The group describes AI as an assistant rather than an autonomous content author. Useful applications include simplifying unfamiliar technical concepts, generating baseline interview questions, critiquing drafts, finding patterns in customer transcripts, and applying proven copywriting examples to new material.

  • Ask AI to explain unfamiliar subjects at an appropriate level
  • Generate baseline interview questions, then improve on them
  • Mine customer transcripts for recurring problems and exact language
  • Provide strong examples and context to improve AI output
  • Use AI to critique hooks and identify weaknesses in drafts

I've also used it sometimes to almost like prompt me to create better questions.

Steph Smith · 20:00

if you give it context beforehand, we've talked about this in the show before. Yeah. Whatever that training data is, like that little bit of…

Kieran Flanagan · 23:00
#ai#research#copywriting#customer-research#chatgpt

Takeaway· 4

Takeaway02:30

Your Content Reflects How You Spend Your Attention

Steph explains that an interesting public voice begins with cultivating interesting inputs and experiences. A creator's output naturally reflects what they read, listen to, explore, and do each day.

  • Lead an interesting life rather than manufacturing an online persona
  • Curate newsletters, podcasts, and other information sources deliberately
  • Treat your public output as a reflection of your daily attention

Twitter to me was just this outlet for me to share the things that I wanted to say.

Steph Smith · 02:30

your outward Twitter feed is inevitably a reflection of the way that you spend your day to day.

Steph Smith · 03:30
#creativity#content#research#personal-brand
Takeaway09:30

Listen to Feedback Without Surrendering Your Point of View

Fast audience feedback can improve creative work, but blindly following every reaction pulls a creator in conflicting directions. A strong point of view helps determine which criticism deserves action and which feedback is incompatible with the creator's intended path.

  • Hear audience feedback without treating every response as a command
  • Use a point of view to filter conflicting reactions
  • Continue worthwhile projects even when early engagement is weak
  • Accept useful criticism without abandoning creative conviction

you need to listen to the people, the users, the consumers of your content, or you could also say the algorithm.

Steph Smith · 11:00

if you don't have a point of view, then you listen to everybody and you just get pulled in a hundred different directions.

Kieran Flanagan · 11:30
#feedback#point-of-view#decision-making#creativity
Takeaway34:30

A Modern Podcast Should Be Designed for Video First

Audio-only podcast analytics provide little useful feedback, while YouTube offers richer measurement and built-in distribution. The speakers recommend creating material that works visually—through demonstrations, graphics, charts, and native video concepts—while ensuring it remains intelligible in the audio feed.

  • Avoid launching an audio-only show when audience growth is the objective
  • Use YouTube for richer analytics and distribution
  • Include charts, graphics, demonstrations, and other visual examples
  • Prefer video-first content that can also succeed as audio
  • Expect some topics to perform differently across video and RSS

If you want hundreds or thousands of people to listen to you, you have to do video in addition to audience.

Steph Smith · 35:30

I find that the content that you create for YouTube applies better to the audio feed than the reverse right exactly the exact same thing.

Steph Smith · 38:30
#youtube#podcasting#video#analytics#distribution
Takeaway39:30

Podcast Growth Comes From Trusted Recommendations and Shareable Ideas

Podcast growth is difficult because native distribution and analytics are weak. Steph identifies cross-promotions with aligned shows, idea seeding on social platforms, distinctive episode packaging, and word of mouth as more effective than generic paid acquisition, which often produces subscribers who do not stay.

  • Cross-promote with podcasts serving similar audiences
  • Recommend only shows the host genuinely knows and likes
  • Seed provocative episode ideas on platforms with stronger distribution
  • Follow successful social posts with relevant podcast material
  • Create distinctive, shareable episodes that inspire word of mouth
  • Treat paid podcast subscribers cautiously because retention may be poor

cross promos are something that we do quite a bit of.

Steph Smith · 40:30

the best way I've seen to grow something is to go on other platforms where you do have distribution and analytics, and then, you know,…

Steph Smith · 42:30
#podcast-growth#distribution#cross-promotion#word-of-mouth#packaging