MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
14 August 2025

Turn GPT-5 into Your Creative Writer with this one trick

5Frameworks
10Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take01:00

Why Copy-Paste AI Marketing Produces Forgettable Content

AI should support research, strategy, analysis, and ideation rather than replace the marketer responsible for the final asset. Copying model output directly into production reduces the human role to data entry and predictably produces generic content.

  • Treat AI as an assistant and thought partner
  • Keep human judgment in the final creation stage
  • Avoid publishing raw model output
  • Use professional skills to transform AI-generated material

AI is an assistant. You are the one with the skills to turn the things that AI gives you into really great assets.

02:30

you never outsource the actual content creation, final content creation to AI.

02:30
#ai writing#marketing#content quality#human judgment

Explainer· 2

Explainer03:00

A Content ICP Is Different from an Ideal Customer Profile

A conventional ICP defines the customer who buys a product or service. A content ICP instead captures the specific audience for the content, including its language, motivations, consumption habits, triggers, and preferred presentation styles.

  • Separate the content audience from the sales profile
  • Document how the audience consumes information
  • Capture motivations and psychological triggers
  • Use the profile to guide writing choices

You need to have a content ICP to create great content via AI.

04:00

An ICP is an ideal customer profile. Who we are selling our products and services to. What we are creating here is a content ICP.…

06:00
#content icp#audience research#persona#content strategy
Explainer03:30

What Content Must Do for a Defensive VP of Marketing

The example profile depicts VP-level marketers as data-driven but overwhelmed professionals who continually need to justify marketing to skeptical executives. Content succeeds with this audience when it supplies concise, credible evidence they can apply or share internally.

  • Address pressure to prove marketing's value
  • Provide material useful in executive conversations
  • Favor immediate application over abstract discussion
  • Connect recommendations to budget defense and credibility

They don't buy features, they buy ammunition for internal political battles.

04:30

They want executive ammunition disguised as marketing insights.

05:00
#vp marketing#b2b saas#audience psychology#executive communication

Story· 1

Story12:30

Three Tests Show How Audience Context Changes GPT-5 Output

GPT-5 is tested on headline hooks, a cross-domain analogy, and a sequential video advertisement. Across all three tasks, the stored VP-marketing profile repeatedly pulls the writing toward boardroom pressure, ROI proof, fragmented metrics, and budget justification.

  • Generate hooks with varied creative devices
  • Explain a concept through an unrelated analogy
  • Draft a sequence of self-contained video clips
  • Check whether outputs reflect audience-specific motivations
  • Iterate on the model's first draft rather than publishing it

We call this the cross-domain analogy test.

14:30

Gets you a first version that you could really iterate on.

17:30
#gpt-5#creative writing#headlines#video ads

Tool· 3

Tool05:30

The Internal Data Sources That Reveal Audience Language

Customer interviews, win-loss notes, CRM records, campaign results, and content-performance reports can establish an evidence-based audience profile. These sources reveal how customers describe their problems, which content influenced them, and why they purchased.

  • Collect customer-call transcripts
  • Review win-loss notes and CRM records
  • Analyze campaign and content performance
  • Extract customers' own language
  • Identify content that influenced purchases

Main thing is if you can get customer call transcripts, one loss notes if you do sales from your CRM records, and then basically any…

06:30

What this will extract is customer language, which is really important.

06:30
#customer research#crm#win loss#voice of customer
Tool09:00

Use Perplexity to Enrich an Internal Audience Skeleton

Internal evidence can provide the skeleton of a content audience profile, while external research fills in consumption habits, preferred formats, effective hooks, trusted sources, and writing patterns. The resulting research should then be condensed into a practical audience description rather than retained as an unwieldy strategy document.

  • Begin with an internally grounded persona
  • Research consumption habits and format preferences
  • Study hooks, language, topics, and credibility markers
  • Condense the findings into a usable audience description

we give perplexity the persona we've created from that internal data, and then we ask it to start to pair it with external data.

09:00

you have the ability to take the internal data and craft a skeleton version of your ideal customer profile in terms of their content preferences…

11:00
#perplexity#external research#content preferences#audience profile
Tool11:30

Store Named Audience Profiles in ChatGPT Memory

A condensed audience description can be stored under a recognizable name and recalled across new chats. Writers can maintain multiple audience profiles and explicitly reference the relevant one whenever they request headlines, analogies, ads, or other creative material.

  • Give each audience profile a distinct name
  • Store the complete description in model memory
  • Reference the audience in every creative request
  • Maintain separate profiles for different audiences

Anytime I want to craft content for this audience, I just sort of sort of inscription in memory.

12:00

Now you can have multiple audiences stored, right?

12:30
#chatgpt memory#prompting#personalization#audience targeting

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway07:30

Score Audience Profiles by the Evidence Behind Them

An audience profile should disclose how much supporting internal evidence was available. A low, medium, or high confidence assessment makes it easier to decide whether external research is essential, useful for validation, or merely supplementary.

  • Tie confidence to the volume and quality of internal data
  • Use external research when internal evidence is limited
  • Validate partially supported audience assumptions
  • Expose data gaps instead of hiding uncertainty

it gives you a confidence level of how accurate this ICP would be based upon how much internal data you actually had

07:30

Limited internal data, you should rely more heavily on the external research.

08:00
#data quality#confidence score#audience research#validation
Takeaway12:30

Add “No Buzzwords” to Every AI Writing Brief

The episode recommends making the prohibition on buzzwords explicit in creative prompts. This simple constraint reduces stereotypical AI phrasing and helps produce cleaner, more direct copy.

  • State the no-buzzwords constraint explicitly
  • Reject vague marketing jargon
  • Prefer concrete audience language
  • Review outputs for AI-style phrasing

Always put no buzzwords. I cannot emphasize this enough.

12:30

No buzzwords. Look how much better it is when it doesn't do like buzzword lingo.

14:00
#buzzwords#copywriting#prompting#editing
Takeaway17:30

GPT-5 Is a Strong First-Draft Partner, Not a Publisher

The episode's verdict is that GPT-5 performs useful creative work when given detailed audience context. Its output can provide a strong first version, but it still requires human selection, revision, and ownership before publication.

  • Use audience context to improve relevance
  • Treat generated copy as a starting point
  • Iterate before publishing
  • Retain human responsibility for the final asset

I do think GPT 5 is doing good creative work here.

17:30

Can you copy and paste what it gives you and put it out there? No.

18:00
#gpt-5#creative assistant#editing#ai content