MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
02 May 2023

Use This A.I. Marketing Strategy To Grow Your Business In 2023 (#114)

5Frameworks
12Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 3

Hot Take17:00

LLMs Can Defend the Low End of a Market

Smaller customers are often more price-sensitive and require more help even though they generate less revenue. LLMs can lower the cost of personalized assistance, allowing established companies to serve those customers more like enterprise accounts and reducing the opening for bottom-up disruption.

  • Small customers can demand disproportionate support.
  • Businesses often respond by concentrating on enterprise accounts.
  • LLMs lower the marginal cost of personalized service.
  • Better low-end service can strengthen competitive defense.

they enable you to serve that $200 customer in a way similar to the way you would serve that $20,000 customer

Kipp Bodnar · 17:30

startups and competitors come in from underneath them and disrupt them.

Kipp Bodnar · 18:00
#customer-service#market-defense#personalization#llms
Hot Take22:00

The Best AI Experiences Will Not Look Like AI

The hosts predict that successful AI products will often hide the underlying model behind an ordinary web or product interface. Users will notice a dramatically more specific and valuable experience rather than being asked to interact explicitly with “AI.”

  • AI does not need to be the visible interface.
  • The user should perceive better outcomes rather than technical novelty.
  • Models can replace generic outputs with specific ones.
  • Invisible AI can make familiar products feel substantially more capable.

the end user is not gonna know they're using AI.

Kipp Bodnar · 22:30

the end product is going to feel 10 times as magical as it does from other businesses

Kipp Bodnar · 22:30
#product-design#user-experience#ai-products
Hot Take27:00

AI Marketing Advantages May Last Years, Not Decades

Kieran warns that widespread AI adoption may accelerate diminishing returns as competitors copy successful tactics. Kipp argues that even a shortened advantage window of roughly 18 to 36 months is long enough to move a business into its next growth phase.

  • Marketing tactics weaken as adoption increases.
  • AI may compress historical adoption curves.
  • A temporary advantage can still create substantial business value.
  • Teams should act despite knowing the tactic will not remain novel forever.

You still have a couple of years of benefit. It's not like days or weeks of benefit.

Kipp Bodnar · 28:30

you'll have 18 to 36 months of benefit

Kipp Bodnar · 28:30
#competitive-advantage#diminishing-returns#marketing-tactics#timing

Explainer· 2

Explainer30:00

AI Can Match Zapier Users to the Right Workflow

A horizontal automation product offers so many possible workflows that users can struggle to identify the one relevant to them. Zapier sees AI as a way to infer a close match between a user’s needs and an automation, replacing generic recommendations with contextual guidance.

  • Horizontal products create choice overload.
  • Generic segmentation cannot capture every automation need.
  • AI can infer likely workflows from user context.
  • A close recommendation can move users through the funnel.

there's an infinite amount of things you can automate.

Kieran Flanagan · 30:30

if we can just get to close, like we can get the close of the... In terms of what you wanna automate, that's hugely positive

Kieran Flanagan · 30:30
#zapier#automation#recommendations#product-led-growth
Explainer31:30

Give Every Customer a Virtual Chief Customer Officer

The hosts imagine a persistent customer copilot that provides individualized onboarding, answers questions, gathers feedback, and adapts the web and product experience. Such a concierge could make high-touch customer guidance available continuously and at scale.

  • Onboarding can be generated for each individual customer.
  • The assistant remains available throughout the customer journey.
  • It can answer questions and collect feedback.
  • The concept extends sales and success copilots directly to customers.

you can have your own concierge continually just giving you an onboarding guide just for you

Kieran Flanagan · 31:30

Everyone gets a chief customer officer.

Kieran Flanagan · 32:00
#customer-copilot#onboarding#customer-success#personalization

Story· 1

Story11:30

Why HubSpot Built a Private ChatGPT Wrapper

HubSpot built an internal ChatGPT-style interface on the OpenAI API so employees could use generative AI without sending business content into a public training workflow. The example illustrates how a centrally supplied secure tool can unlock broad employee experimentation before an official enterprise product is available.

  • Public AI tools raised concerns about business-data handling.
  • HubSpot created a web wrapper around its business API access.
  • The internal interface preserved a familiar ChatGPT-like experience.
  • Shared infrastructure enabled safer organization-wide adoption.

We built HubSpotGPT which was just a clone of ChatGPT built on the OpenAI API

Kipp Bodnar · 11:30

none of the information would go into the training model.

Kipp Bodnar · 12:30
#privacy#enterprise-ai#hubspot#infrastructure

Tool· 3

Tool26:00

Personalize the First Nurture Message with Behavioral Data

First-conversion nurturing is typically generic because companies know little about a new lead. HubSpot is testing LLM-generated email copy based on company information and user behavior to make early messages more relevant and improve conversion.

  • Early nurture messages often lack useful personalization.
  • LLMs can combine company and behavioral context into copy.
  • The primary channel in HubSpot’s example is email.
  • Conversion rate provides a measurable outcome.

we are using large language models to basically more personalize, create the copy for that email, versus the generic copy

Kipp Bodnar · 26:30

to make it hyper-relevant to them, to see if we can transform the conversion rate.

Kipp Bodnar · 26:30
#email#nurturing#personalization#conversion
Tool28:30

Ask Only for Email, Then Let AI Enrich the Record

AI-assisted enrichment can reduce form friction by collecting only an email address at conversion. The system then looks up company and contact details from other data sources and appends them to the record.

  • Shorter forms reduce the information requested upfront.
  • Email acts as the lookup key.
  • External data fills company and contact fields.
  • The enriched record preserves downstream context.

you only collect the email address

Kipp Bodnar · 29:00

the AI goes and looks up all the other information and appends it back to the record.

Kipp Bodnar · 29:00
#forms#data-enrichment#lead-generation#conversion
Tool31:00

Scale Marketplace Pages with AI—Then Prune the Failures

AI can enumerate ways integrations work together and generate pages for those combinations, making large marketplaces or ecommerce catalogs easier to scale. Kieran adds an essential SEO safeguard: automatically deindex pages that attract no traffic so low-value generation does not pollute the site.

  • AI can discover combinations within a large integration catalog.
  • Generated pages can scale long-tail marketplace coverage.
  • The pattern can apply to ecommerce and other large sites.
  • Traffic monitoring should trigger deindexing of unsuccessful pages.

AI can actually go and start to figure out like, here's all of the different ways that these tools can be used and I can…

Kieran Flanagan · 31:00

this content isn't getting any traffic at all, so I'll actually start to DN exit

Kieran Flanagan · 31:30
#marketplaces#seo#programmatic-content#integrations

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway05:30

AI Lets Marketers Build Instead of Waiting for Engineering

AI-assisted development can let marketers create lightweight tools, extensions, and prototypes without waiting in an engineering queue. The strategic gain is not just cheaper production but a shorter cycle between an idea, a public release, and evidence about whether it works.

  • Marketers can prototype lightweight products themselves.
  • Reduced engineering dependency shortens time to launch.
  • Faster launches produce faster market learning.
  • Lower resource requirements make unfamiliar ideas less risky.

I'll just go build it on Replit, right?

Kieran Flanagan · 06:30

The resourcing necessary to do some of the new AI work is much lower than before.

Kipp Bodnar · 09:00
#ai#prototyping#replit#freemium#experimentation
Takeaway23:00

AI Teams Should Play Offense While Leaders Clear the Field

Frontline employees should actively explore how AI changes their roles instead of waiting for leadership to prescribe every use. Leaders should expect to moderate demand, approve tools, and remove constraints rather than repeatedly push an inactive team to experiment.

  • Individuals should understand AI’s impact on their own work.
  • Breakthroughs often come from people with deep role knowledge.
  • Leaders should remove access and approval blockers.
  • High experimentation demand is healthier than organizational passivity.

You want the team to be playing offense and the leader to play... Be playing defense.

Kipp Bodnar · 25:30

the best breakthroughs come from individuals

Kieran Flanagan · 24:30
#leadership#culture#experimentation#teams
Takeaway29:00

Website Chat Is the Most Obvious AI Conversion Use Case

Kipp identifies website chat as an especially promising application because chat users already tend to be high-converting visitors. Faster and higher-quality engagement could lift conversion throughout the rest of the funnel, although the hosts acknowledge that required answer precision remains an open question.

  • Website chat attracts high-intent visitors.
  • AI can increase response speed.
  • Better responses may improve downstream conversion.
  • Teams must test whether close answers are sufficient.

I think that is by far the number one most obvious AI use case.

Kipp Bodnar · 29:30

your down cycle conversion rates on everything are gonna go through the roof.

Kipp Bodnar · 29:30
#website-chat#lead-conversion#customer-engagement#llms