Building-Mode and Operating-Mode Channel Portfolio
Balance predictable channels with emerging channels that can create outsized returns
- Difficulty
- Advanced
- Time to result
- ~months to results
- Steps
- 5
- Confidence
- 97%
Divide marketing channels into building mode and operating mode. Building-mode channels are still expanding their products, audiences, and monetization systems, so their incentives tend to align with early marketers and can produce disproportionate returns. Operating-mode channels optimize established economics and cash flow; they can remain effective, but their returns become predictable and often more expensive. Audit the portfolio, classify each channel, and choose an intentional allocation based on company maturity, trajectory, downside exposure, and need for growth. Established companies may target a substantial balance between the two modes, while scrappier challengers can accept more uncertainty. The objective is not to abandon reliable channels but to avoid relying exclusively on yesterday's advantages.
Origin
Kip Bodner proposed the building-versus-operating distinction on Marketing Against The Grain while discussing the decline of organic search returns and the emergence of community-led channels.
Core principles
- 01Operating channels provide predictable returns
- 02Building channels align their growth incentives with early adopters
- 03Emerging channels offer greater upside and uncertainty
- 04A healthy portfolio funds present performance and future advantage
- 05Allocation should reflect the business's stage and risk capacity
How to run it
- 1
Inventory the channel portfolio
List every meaningful marketing channel, its cost, its role, and the business outcomes it currently supports.
Pro tip Include community and experimental initiatives even when their attribution is incomplete.
Watch out Do not omit small channels merely because they lack mature reporting.
- 2
Classify each channel's mode
Mark a channel as building when it is expanding and still developing monetization, or operating when it is optimizing established economics and cash flow.
Pro tip Assess the platform's incentives, not just your internal maturity on that platform.
Watch out A new campaign on a mature advertising platform is not necessarily a building-mode investment.
- 3
Choose an intentional mix
Allocate enough to operating channels to support predictable performance and enough to building channels to create future upside. Adjust the balance to the company's stage and exposure to failure.
Pro tip Use a range rather than treating one percentage as universally correct.
Watch out A nominal innovation budget can leave the portfolio effectively concentrated in operating mode.
- 4
Use mode-appropriate expectations
Judge operating channels on efficiency and reliability, while judging building channels on learning, audience response, and signs of emerging advantage.
Pro tip Define learning milestones before demanding direct attribution.
Watch out Applying mature-channel ROI thresholds too early will kill promising experiments.
- 5
Reclassify over time
Review whether each channel is moving from building to operating mode as monetization, competition, measurement, and costs mature.
Pro tip Shift resources before rising certainty eliminates the outsized return.
Watch out Do not preserve an allocation merely because it worked in a previous market phase.
In the wild
An established software company keeps search and paid acquisition as dependable operating channels but redirects a meaningful share of its budget toward a Discord community and creator-led video experiments. The new initiatives receive learning and engagement goals before revenue targets.
→ The company preserves near-term demand while developing direct audience relationships and potential new growth advantages.
A recently funded startup cannot outspend a category leader on mature search terms, so it experiments in an underused social format where the leader is unwilling to risk its brand. It develops expertise before the channel becomes crowded.
→ The challenger earns attention and market share at a lower early-stage cost.
Common mistakes
Putting everything in operating mode
A portfolio of mature channels may look safe while steadily losing differentiation and becoming more expensive.
Treating experiments like mature programs
Demanding immediate linear attribution from a building-mode channel prevents the learning needed to create an advantage.
Ignoring downside capacity
The ideal allocation depends on what the company can lose, including capital, reputation, and focus—not merely the cash cost of entry.
Is it for you?
Best for
It is best for marketing leaders allocating resources between dependable acquisition programs and uncertain emerging opportunities.
Not ideal for
It is not ideal for a company that lacks enough runway to fund any learning beyond immediate survival.
From the transcript
“you're really talking about channels that are in operating mode or building mode.”
“What you have to do is determine what is the mix between those operator channels and those building channels, and you have to make that…”
“if you want to drive growth and stay ahead, you have to make those moves into channels that make you a little bit uncomfortable”
From the episode
Be The Most Interesting Brand In Your Market with Ross Simmonds
Ross Simmonds