MMarketing Against The Grain
← All episodes
21 February 2023

Ranking 2023's Top 6 Marketing Strategies

3Frameworks
12Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster21:00

Millions of Video Views Do Not Automatically Mean Business Value

Short-form video benefits from powerful consumer-attention trends, but B2B marketers still struggle to connect reach with business outcomes. The hosts believe video is strategically important while cautioning that measurement and monetization remain immature for many brands.

  • Consumer behavior strongly favors short-form video.
  • B2B adoption remains less mature than B2C and influencer use.
  • Large view counts may not reveal commercial impact.
  • Engagement can still create brand value without direct attribution.
  • Measurement and monetization limitations keep video from being the top priority.

One of our TikTok videos went to like 3 million views. Is that great? I don't know.

Kieran Flanagan · 22:00

The other one is monetization, right?

Kipp Bodnar · 22:30
#video#tiktok#youtube#measurement#b2b

Hot Take· 3

Hot Take10:30

Perfect Direct-Response Attribution Is Going Away

Data regulation is eroding the precise attribution marketers have come to expect from digital advertising. The likely replacement is a greater reliance on influence metrics, including view-through relationships between exposure, brand effects, and business outcomes.

  • Regulation is weakening deterministic advertising attribution.
  • Exact return-on-ad-spend reporting will become harder to sustain.
  • Platforms are promoting view-through conversion measures.
  • Influence metrics may better describe advertising’s contribution.
  • Marketers must accept weaker direct correlation between spend and outcomes.

That's going away. That is going away and it's not because people are tired of it. It's regulatory issues are forcing that to go away.

Kipp Bodnar · 11:00

I think that the era of influence metrics is gonna be upon us, right.

Kieran Flanagan · 11:30
#privacy#attribution#advertising#measurement
Hot Take19:30

Why Email Marketing Missed the Top Six

Email remains valuable, but the hosts see no meaningful new tailwinds supporting it. Data privacy, rising email volume, and increasingly homogeneous AI-written messages create modest but real headwinds.

  • Email continues to function as an established marketing channel.
  • Data privacy changes affect email marketing.
  • Companies are sending increasing volumes of email.
  • AI-generated messages risk sounding alike.
  • The channel has new headwinds but no comparable new tailwinds.

There's a couple new headwinds. They're not crazy but they're real and there's no new tailwinds.

Kipp Bodnar · 20:30

Everyone's getting more email and they all sign the same 'cause they're written by the same chat bots

Kieran Flanagan · 20:30
#email#privacy#ai writing#channels
Hot Take24:00

SEO Remains Powerful but Faces Multiple Headwinds

Search engine optimization remains a major growth strategy, but declining organic click-through rates, AI-generated answers, and weaker software demand create uncertainty. Established sites may turn AI into an advantage by reducing content-production costs and leveraging existing domain authority.

  • Organic click-through rates are declining.
  • AI answers may reduce traffic sent to websites.
  • Software demand has weakened in the current economic environment.
  • Established domain authority remains an important advantage.
  • AI can lower content-production costs for capable teams.

I think it's gonna be a tricky year for search.

Kieran Flanagan · 24:30

You could actually turn AI into a tailwind versus a headwind.

Kieran Flanagan · 24:30
#seo#organic search#ai#content

Explainer· 5

Explainer02:30

Why Smaller Budgets Are Making B2B Purchases Slower

Budget cuts and economic caution are lengthening buying cycles, particularly for companies selling into the technology sector. More stakeholders are joining buying committees because organizations are increasingly reluctant to commit money or sign contracts.

  • Technology vendors face especially severe customer budget cuts.
  • Even healthier industries are holding budgets flat and spending cautiously.
  • Buying cycles are slowing across industries.
  • More stakeholders are participating in considered purchases.
  • Provider consolidation is reducing the number of bills companies maintain.

The number of people involved in making a considered purchase are getting bigger.

Kipp Bodnar · 03:30

They are trying to be very cautious of their expense in a world of uncertain economic times, right.

Kipp Bodnar · 05:00
#b2b#budgets#buying committees#sales
Explainer06:30

Why Event Production Costs Rose as Much as 45%

Physical-event production costs were reported to be 20% to 45% higher, depending on the market. Material inflation and a smaller post-Covid event workforce mean suppliers can concentrate on highly profitable work rather than accepting marginal jobs to cover payroll.

  • Event production costs are up 20% to 45% in some markets.
  • Materials became more expensive because of supply-chain and related pressures.
  • Many event workers left the industry during Covid.
  • Smaller production teams can be more selective about projects.
  • Historical event budgets may no longer be realistic.

event production costs are up 20 to 45% depending on the market and everything.

Kipp Bodnar · 07:00

A lot of the workforce in the event world left.

Kipp Bodnar · 07:00
#events#costs#labor#marketing
Explainer09:30

Consumers Want More Value Before They Pay

Customers increasingly expect video, concise answers, self-service access, transparent pricing, and useful product information. The hosts connect the popularity of conversational AI with a broader preference for technology that performs more work and reduces friction.

  • Short-form video consumption continues to expand.
  • Users are increasingly comfortable receiving one synthesized answer.
  • Self-service experiences are becoming standard across industries.
  • Transparent pricing and better product information reduce friction.
  • Customers expect to experience more value before committing money.

Users want to have self-serve. And they want better product information, transparent pricing, all of those things

Kipp Bodnar · 10:00

consumers want more value before they actually commit to doing, to giving you money.

Kieran Flanagan · 10:30
#consumer behavior#self-service#pricing#ai
Explainer12:30

The Four Forces Disrupting Search Advertising

The AdWords model faces simultaneous pressure from privacy restrictions, conversational interfaces that displace links, fragmentation across advertising channels, and mobile users’ preference for direct answers. Together, these forces threaten both targeting and the search-result surface where ads traditionally appear.

  • Privacy changes weaken targeting and attribution.
  • Chat interfaces may displace links on search-result pages.
  • Google and Meta hold less than half of online ad market share combined.
  • Creators, retail platforms, and emerging channels fragment ad spending.
  • No-click searches are especially common on mobile.

Google and Meta's combined market share is lower than it has been since 2014. It's sub 50% of the online ad market share

Kipp Bodnar · 13:00

On mobile, I think it's something like upwards of near 85, 90%.

Kieran Flanagan · 14:30
#adwords#search#advertising#chatbots#mobile
Explainer28:00

Falling Ad Costs Favor Businesses With Strong Unit Economics

Lower CPMs create an opening for financially healthy companies to accelerate paid acquisition while weaker competitors cut spending. The opportunity depends on having enough economic margin to reinvest without relying on the precise attribution marketers previously enjoyed.

  • Advertising costs are falling as competition decreases.
  • Healthy businesses can reinvest strong unit economics into acquisition.
  • Competitors with fragile economics are withdrawing budget.
  • Paid media can generate both direct and indirect returns.
  • Reporting may become less precise even as prices become more attractive.

When costs come down. The reason they're doing that is because competition is decreasing.

Kieran Flanagan · 28:30

You're like, "Oh, well now I can actually accelerate my growth a little bit through paid advertising in a really kind of cost efficient way."

Kieran Flanagan · 29:00
#paid ads#unit economics#cpm#growth

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway08:00

Higher Employee Retention Can Unlock Better Long-Term Work

A tighter labor market can improve employee retention, allowing sales representatives and marketers to accumulate experience and sustain longer-term initiatives. The hosts argue that continuity is a meaningful advantage because ambitious work requires patience and stable teams.

  • Employees and sales representatives are staying longer.
  • Longer tenure can improve experience and productivity.
  • Team continuity supports long-term strategies.
  • A strong talent market creates hiring opportunities.
  • Important work generally takes time to mature.

That great work takes patience.

Kieran Flanagan · 09:00

To accomplish anything great takes a long time.

Kipp Bodnar · 09:00
#retention#talent#teams#long-term strategy
Takeaway26:30

Use a Slow Year to Fix Messaging and Positioning

When performance marketing is constrained by economic conditions, product marketing can prepare the business for the next demand cycle. Sharper messaging, storytelling, and positioning also help address larger buying committees and weaker close rates.

  • Performance channels operate on short monthly and quarterly cycles.
  • Economic pressure can suppress performance-marketing results.
  • A slower period creates room to improve positioning.
  • Stronger messaging prepares the business for renewed demand.
  • Product marketing can support complex buying committees.

it's a really great year to lean in to your messaging and positioning.

Kieran Flanagan · 27:00

you have really nailed the messaging. - Love that.

Kieran Flanagan · 27:00
#product marketing#positioning#messaging#b2b
Takeaway31:00

Strong Brands Connect Products to Customer Identity

The hosts rank brand marketing first because emotional storytelling can influence buying committees and strengthen positioning while direct-response measurement deteriorates. They argue that brands become more powerful when customers see part of their own identity in the product and its community.

  • People often make decisions emotionally rather than rationally.
  • Brand stories can educate and persuade complex buying committees.
  • Lower advertising costs create opportunities for brand investment.
  • Influence is becoming more important as direct attribution weakens.
  • Products can create tribes by connecting with customer identity.

People make decisions emotionally not rationally.

Kipp Bodnar · 31:30

People do not have enough identity. And brand is a powerful way to help people connect identity to your product, your service

Kipp Bodnar · 33:30
#brand#storytelling#identity#positioning#influence